Israel and Türkiye must clarify their red lines on Syria

Discussions aimed at reaching a mutual understanding are vital to preventing miscalculation from either side

Turkey's President Recep Tayyip Erdogan (R) meeting with Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu (L) on the sidelines of the 78th United Nations General Assembly at UN headquarters in New York City on September 19, 2023.
Turkish Presidency Press Office / AFP
Turkey's President Recep Tayyip Erdogan (R) meeting with Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu (L) on the sidelines of the 78th United Nations General Assembly at UN headquarters in New York City on September 19, 2023.

Israel and Türkiye must clarify their red lines on Syria

The collapse of the Assad regime has reshaped the regional landscape. But while there is a broad international consensus in support of Syria's new leader, Ahmed al-Sharaa—with a clear preference for a unified country under a centralised authority over continued chaos—serious doubts remain whether he can bring long-term stability.

The rapid withdrawal of Iran from Syria opens a window of opportunity for regional stability. As such, what happens in Syria greatly matters to international stakeholders like the US, but also regional stakeholders like Israel and Türkiye.

What Israel wants

For its part, Israel worries about the possible emergence of a radical Islamist government in Damascus and creeping Turkish influence along its border. And while Tel Aviv has seemingly come to terms with Ankara's heavy involvement in northern Syria—particularly in Kurdish areas—it appears to have drawn a red line regarding Turkish military presence in other parts of the country.

Moreover, Israel has not yet decided whether it prefers a strong centralised government in Damascus or a weak and fractured state, although recent statements and actions suggest a preference for the latter. Its final calculus will likely be shaped by Washington's position, but regardless, given its demonstrated military superiority in recent months, Israel will want to play a key role in shaping Syria’s future.

 Ozan Kose/AFP
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan (R) and Syria's interim president Ahmed al-Sharaa shake hands during a joint press conference following their meeting at the Presidential Palace in Ankara, on 4 February 2025.

What Türkiye wants

As for Türkiye, it sees an opportunity to secure its border with Syria on its own terms, in a manner that aligns with its recent moves vis-à-vis the Kurds, including the PKK. At the same time, it wants to simultaneously deepen Damascus's dependence on Ankara and bolster its regional standing, which its critics would describe as a pursuit of regional hegemony.

Erdoğan's excellent relationship with US President Donald Trump has emboldened him to pursue such a quest, further buoyed by improved relations with Gulf states and Egypt. potential.

With seemingly conflicting interests in Syria, the potential for direct confrontation cannot be ruled out. Discussions aimed at reaching a mutual understanding are vital to preventing miscalculation from either side. Tri-party talks between Ankara, Tel-Aviv and Washington are welcome, as are direct or discreet talks between Türkiye and Israel, as well as Azerbaijani mediation.

Israel's finger-on-the-trigger approach in Syria unsettles not only Ankara but also Washington

Israel's finger-on-the-trigger approach in Syria unsettles not only Ankara but also Washington. Israel may be trying to play the Druze card in the same way that Türkiye plays the Kurdish card to justify its expansion into Syria, but in reality, the two are quite different. At the same time, Türkiye's involvement in Syria not only unnerves Israel but also other regional stakeholders. But this should in no way be likened to Iranian involvement.

And finally, Israel would be smart to walk back its ego following its string of military successes across the region, lest it fall into the trap of reckless adventurism. Adopting a rational strategy going forward could help it safeguard its tactical wins.

Whether or not Israel and Türkiye can reach a mutually accepted agreement over Syria remains to be seen, but given the high stakes involved, it would be foolish for either party to press its luck.

font change

Related Articles