Downfall of Delhi darling Hasina creates uncertainties for India

The ousted Bangladeshi autocrat Sheikh Hasina relied on India for years, while India put all its eggs in the Hasina basket. Now she has fled the country and everyone looks silly

Ousted Bangladesh Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina (L) waves as Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi (R) hosts her in a ceremonial reception in New Delhi on April 8, 2017.
Prakesh Singh/AFP
Ousted Bangladesh Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina (L) waves as Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi (R) hosts her in a ceremonial reception in New Delhi on April 8, 2017.

Downfall of Delhi darling Hasina creates uncertainties for India

Bangladesh’s Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina landed at an Indian Air Force base near New Delhi within hours of resigning on 5 August. It was her natural safe haven.

Hasina has spent years cultivating relations with India, whose national security advisor, Ajit Doval, a key official in Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government, met the ousted Bangladeshi leader at the Hindon military base, along with senior military officials.

There was no immediate comment on Hasina from India's Ministry of External Affairs, despite successive Indian governments building their Bangladesh policy around her.

On 6 August, Indian Foreign Minister Subrahmanyam Jaishankar told parliament that Hasina requested permission to come to India “at very short notice”, adding: “We simultaneously received a request for flight clearance from Bangladesh authorities.”

Urgent recalibration

India-Bangladesh relations “have been exceptionally close for many decades, over many governments,” said Jaishankar, but “since the election in January 2024 (that Hasina controversially won), there has been considerable tensions, deep divides and growing polarisation in Bangladesh politics”.

Mohammad Ponir Hossain/Reuters
A man poses at the Ganabhaban, the Prime Minister's residence, after the resignation Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina in Dhaka, Bangladesh, August 5, 2024.

Jaishankar’s statement suggests that India knew for months that Hasina was in trouble, but the Modi government may have underestimated the extent of public anger against her, or else hoped that she would eventually prevail.

The Indian media has painted Hasina’s exit as having serious consequences for bilateral relations. With India’s preferred leader gone, Bangladesh’s relations with other countries—including India’s adversaries, Pakistan and China—will likely change.

With India's preferred leader gone, Bangladesh's relations with other countries—including India's adversaries, Pakistan and China—will likely change

One editorial praised her economic policies and for being a "great friend of India" but said she "sowed the seeds of her downfall" and warned that uncertainties lay ahead.

Although Jaishankar said the situation was "still evolving," it seems highly likely at this stage that Bangladeshis will insist on a leader who does not so ruthlessly destroy the country's political opposition, as Hasina did uninterrupted for 15 years.

Protests' cause and effect

The large-scale student-led protests that broke out in July were fueled by several issues. One was the way Hasina had whittled away Bangladesh's independence by becoming too dependent on India.

Wolfgang Rattay/Reuters
The ousted Bangladeshi Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina speaks during the annual Munich Security Conference on February 17, 2024.

Protesters demanded an end to the quota system that reserved up to 30% of government jobs for relatives of those who participated in the 1971 independence war.

This outdated system, seen as a conduit for corruption and Awami League patronage, only shrank the jobs market further for Bangladesh's educated youth.

On 21 July, the Supreme Court scrapped most job quotas by reducing the share of reserved jobs from 56% of all positions to just 7%, but that failed to calm the protests, and the government's violent crackdown only added fuel to the fire.

At the time of writing, more than 400 had been killed, thousands injured, and more than 10,000 arrested. Almost 100 people were killed in a single day on 4 August.

Frustration with India

Anger directed at Hasina's authoritarianism has an anti-India element. India invested heavily in Hasina, 76, without building relations with other parties, including the Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP) and Bangladesh Jamaat-e-Islami.

Olympia de Maismont/AFP
Crowds celebrate as Bangladeshi Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina's 15-year rule ended on August 5, 2024 as she fled after more than a month of deadly protests.

The daughter of the nation's independence war leader Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, Hasina first became prime minister in 1996, serving a five-year term.

She returned to power in 2009 and in January of this year she was declared the winner for a fourth time.

More than 400 have been killed in the protests, thousands injured, and more than 10,000 arrested. Almost 100 were killed in a single day in August

Serious allegations of fraud, political manipulation, and a lack of opposition participation were levelled at her and the Awami League, which typically dismisses its opponents as "extremists" and "terrorists". Those opponents said Hasina was trying to establish a perpetual one-party rule and that India was helping her.

While she is currently in India, there is no certainty that she will stay there. Reports in India suggest that she may be on her way to London, but the British government has not yet agreed to grant her political asylum.

Surveying the aftermath

In a statement on 5 August, British Foreign Secretary David Lammy seemed to suggest the UK may not welcome Hasina, saying Bangladeshis "deserve a full and independent UN-led investigation into the events of the past few weeks".

Munir Uz Zaman/AFP
Anti-government protestors wave Bangladesh's national flag as they celebrate near Dhaka University on August 5, 2024.

Bangladesh's Chief of Staff Gen. Waker-Uz-Zaman said the new government in Dhaka would "ensure that justice is served for every death and crime that occurred during the protests," but after years of corruption, people may not believe him.

Until then, Hasina will feel at home in India, in part because her daughter, Saima Wazed, is regional director for World Health Organisation for South-East Asia, based in Delhi. Yet it may not be in India's interests for Hasina to stay. Hosting her in exile could make it difficult for New Delhi to build bridges with Dhaka's new rulers.

In trade, business contracts, border security, and logistics access, Hasina delivered what India wanted. She was Delhi's darling, lionised by the Indian media, while her domestic opponents were seen with suspicion, apathy and rancour.

Her surprise and sudden departure now embarrassed New Delhi, which put all its eggs in the 'Hasina basket', just as she had happily over-relied on India.

Abrupt new reality

The sharp rupture is likely to challenge India's trade and economic relations with Bangladesh, which has a massive trade deficit with India and remains a key destination for Indian goods and services.

In trade, business contracts, border security, and logistics access, Hasina delivered what India wanted

The political change also creates uncertainties for India's regional projects that are part of New Delhi's 'Act East' policy of getting closer to Asian countries.

Before it is determined whether the new government will be favourably disposed towards India or not, Bangladesh needs political stability and calm to recover from the upheaval it has just experienced.

Mohammad Ponir Hossain/Reuters
A man holding a Bangladesh flag stands in front of a torched vehicle at the Ganabhaban, the Prime Minister's residence, after the resignation of PM Sheikh Hasina in Dhaka, Bangladesh, on August 5, 2024.

For India, there are immediate questions about regional connectivity projects, trade flows, border security, counter-terrorism cooperation, and South Asian regional politics.

The nature of India's future relationship with Bangladesh is likely to be shaped by what Indian officials can get through serious negotiations, trade-offs, and compromises with their counterparts.

Regardless, India can no longer bank on a leader who listens to its concerns and acts on them with the utmost attention to deliver profitable results.

font change

Related Articles