The Lebanese dust is settling; the guns are smoking but silent. People are returning to their homes to survey the damage. Whisper it, but a ceasefire between Israel and Hezbollah appears to be sticking.
But as both warring sides propelled their final volleys towards the other, a futile debate began in earnest: who had won? Had either side achieved its objectives or thwarted the ambitions of its adversary?
This debate is inconsequential because it misses the point. The analysis of regional power dynamics, of Iran’s so-called proxies and the ‘axis of resistance, the bombastic rhetoric of recent years, it all pales in significance compared to what the war has revealed both in Lebanon and the Arab world.
Impact on society
In Lebanon and elsewhere it revealed deep societal fractures—far deeper than many thought—exposing divisions over the idea of the nation-state, the balance between pluralism and unity within the state, and the place of Palestinian rights in Arab politics. Layers of rhetoric long deployed to distort and avoid reality will no longer do.
There have been some positives to take from war. Despite concerns, when war erupted, regions with differing sectarian affiliations did not block the entry of displaced people from Lebanon’s south, Beirut’s southern suburb of Dahiya, or the Bekaa Valley—all areas with high Shiite populations.