If Israel defends minorities, why is it annihilating its own?

The Palestinians are a minority in Israel, yet they are being bombed out of existence in Gaza. Odd, then, to see Israel bomb the Syrian government to defend the existence of another minority.

If Israel defends minorities, why is it annihilating its own?

While Israel has been bombing Syria under the pretext of protecting Syria’s Druze minority, it has been simultaneously engaged in genocide in Gaza and ethnic cleansing in the West Bank, two Palestinian territories under its control and occupation. On the one hand, it attacks others to protect minorities. On the other, it refuses to recognise or treat Palestinians as a minority under its care.

The fear of a majority annihilating a minority is writ deep in the Israeli psyche, a shared Jewish memory of pogroms in Russia and Europe, culminating in the industrial genocide of the Holocaust. This fear, and the memory of past trauma, forms a foundational pillar of the Israeli state, played a critical role in moving large numbers of Jews from across Europe, and laid the ideological groundwork for Zionism in the latter half of the 19th century.

Since then, Israeli discourse—whether under Labour, Likud, or any coalition within its political spectrum—has consistently employed the rhetoric of self-defence against the supposed tyranny of an Arab-Muslim majority seeking to drive the Jews into the sea and obliterate their state. This is propaganda, but it has long benefited from a level of political naivety in the Arab world that borders on wilful complicity.

Building relations

Even before the State of Israel’s establishment, the Yishuv (the Jewish settlement administration) worked assiduously to build relations with religious and ethnic minorities in historic Palestine, like Bedouins, Circassians, Druze, and Christians. Some—like the Druze—were open to it, others were not, while others still engaged in pragmatic bargaining.

Israeli discourse is of self-defence against the tyranny of an Arab-Muslim majority seeking to drive the Jews into the sea and obliterate their state

As the Arab-Israeli conflict expanded over time and geography, successive Israeli governments and agencies nurtured ties in Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, Egypt, Iraq, even Yemen and Ethiopia. These relationships helped facilitate Jewish emigration from these countries while also giving Israel some useful political or security footholds.

Meetings between Israelis and figures from neighbouring states regularly took place, with a view to finding areas of common interest and mutual benefit. Such engagements frequently involved the creation of Israel-aligned factions and alliances, often activated during Arab civil wars, from Lebanon to Sudan. There was nothing secret. It was all overt.

The one exception

Yet despite Israel's broad engagement with minorities across the region, and despite its claims to be ensuring their survival from majorities, Israel has persistently refused to recognise or protect the minority under its responsibility that is facing a clear existential threat: the Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

Of all the region's oppressed and aggrieved ethnicities, religions, peoples, and cultures, the Palestinians are among the least likely to be get the global compassion often extended to an oppressed minorities fighting to survive in their ancestral land. When it comes to the Palestinians, the usual minority-majority calculus simply vanishes.

Of all the region's oppressed and aggrieved minorities, the Palestinians are among the least likely to be get global compassion

In 2018, Israel passed a Basic Law (forming part of its constitution) declaring itself to be the nation-state of the Jewish people, a state comprising a Jewish majority and an Arab minority, both within the 1948 borders and in the territories occupied since 1967.

In fact, many in Israel argue that Palestinians are not even a minority within Israel, but rather part of a broader external 22-nation regional Arab majority, into which the Palestinians could be easily 'absorbed'.

Scientifically refuting such claims is a futile exercise, not because Palestinian identity is distinct from those of neighbouring Arab states, nor because Palestinians are already living on their ancestral land, but because Israelis know these rhetorical contortions are the crude instrumentation of an ethnic cleansing project playing out before our eyes.

The ongoing destruction of Palestinian society in the Gaza Strip—under the guise of rescuing Israeli hostages in a war now approaching two years in length—is a smokescreen for a genocide that even Israel's traditional allies find hard to justify.

font change