Why hasn't Netanyahu hit Iran yet?

Since his threat to hit his foe hard, Benjamin Netanyahu has been weighing up both its method and timing. To understand what has been on his mind, it helps to know what it is he is trying to do.

Relatives and supporters of Israelis held hostage in Gaza since the October 7 attacks call on the US to intervene for their release during a demonstration in Tel Aviv during Antony Blinken's October 22, 2024, visit.
Jack GUEZ / AFP
Relatives and supporters of Israelis held hostage in Gaza since the October 7 attacks call on the US to intervene for their release during a demonstration in Tel Aviv during Antony Blinken's October 22, 2024, visit.

Why hasn't Netanyahu hit Iran yet?

At Hatzerim Airbase on 23 October, Israeli defence minister Yoav Gallant told Israeli pilots that “after we strike Iran, everyone will understand what you did in the preparation and training process”. It was an acknowledgement of the time it has taken Israel to respond to the wave of ballistic missiles fired at Israel from Iran on 1 October.

That Iranian attack, in turn, was in response to Israel’s killing of Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah in Beirut and Hamas leader Ismael Haniyeh in Tehran, hours after he met the country’s Supreme Leader and President, in gross violation of Iranian sovereignty.

The initial expectation was that Israel would retaliate shortly after the attack and would target Iran’s nuclear and oil facilities. Could it be that Israel has heeded Washington’s counsel to limit its military action in a way to avoid further escalation?

Listening to the US

While avoiding regional escalation may indeed be US President Joe Biden’s primary goal, Washington continues to convey mixed signals. On the one hand, it has urged caution. On the other, it was seen to be preparing to support Israel if it attacks Iran.

Just days before Americans go to the polls, Biden clearly does not want Israel to take any action that would lead to regional escalation. The effects of this would almost certainly have a negative impact on the chances of Democrat and Vice President Kamala Harris. Oil prices would jump and Americans would start worrying about the economy.

Vice President Kamala Harris meets Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at the White House on July 25, 2024.

While Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu occasionally listens to the White House, ultimately he does what he thinks is in his personal interest, which does not necessarily coincide with the interests of Israel.

There may be several reasons why he has not yet retaliated against Iran. One is that he is more comfortable postponing or avoiding big decisions, preferring to manoeuvre to gain personal advantage. Yet, this does not provide a full explanation. For that, one needs to consider the objectives of the military mission itself.

Attack objectives

The first reason for Netanyahu to attack Iran is a personal one: to save himself. If he loses political power, his political career will end in disgrace, and he will again face court proceedings for bribery, fraud, and breach of trust while in office.

The second objective is strategic: to drag the United States into a war with Iran. Israel knows that, on its own, it cannot destroy Iran's nuclear programme nor bring about regime change—a Netanyahu aim for 20 years. Since 2003, he has tried every trick in the book to get the US to attack Iran and has not yet given up hope. If Donald Trump wins the White House back, Netanyahu will lick his lips.

The Israeli leader's desire to instigate regime change in Tehran is obvious: his latest message to the Iranian people cannot be interpreted any other way. This is part of a broader plan to reshape the Middle East.

Striking Iran just before America votes lets Netanyahu influence the outcome in favour of Trump, his preferred candidate

Another factor is that Israel, under Netanyahu's leadership, has gone too far. It has violated international law and committed untold atrocities. In short, he can no longer back down unless the US decides to put an end to his actions (unfortunately, there are no indications that it will do so).

Timed to coincide

To achieve his objectives, Netanyahu will be impervious to US interests. While he may accommodate the US on targets, he will choose the timing of the action, and this will likely serve his narrow personal and political interests. As such, he may wait to act as close to the US elections as possible.

Striking Iran just before America votes lets Netanyahu influence the outcome in favour of Trump. This rests on the calculation that the American people, faced with another Middle East war, will elect someone with no hesitation in using force to protect US interests.

Attacking Iran shortly after the winner of the US elections is declared also offers certain advantages for Netanyahu. If Trump is elected, Netanyahu will feel he can proceed with impunity, knowing that Trump gives green lights. If Kamala Harris wins, Israel may have significantly less wiggle room.

When all is said and done, Netanyahu will act based on two factors: what serves his narrow political interests, and what support he can expect to receive from America in his plans to reshape the Middle East.

At this stage, it is unlikely that he will back down from his present policies and direction, unless unprecedented US pressure is brought to bear on him. Let us hope that it is, for the sake of everyone in the Middle East.

font change

Related Articles