Shenzhen: heavy on optics, light on substance

Trump, Xi, and Putin were all keen to be seen together, which may have been the most that could be expected. Still, on nuclear weapons, there were green shoots

US President Donald Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin and China’s President Xi Jinping meet at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in Shenzhen, Guangdong province, on 18 November 2026.
Iori Sagisawa/ REUTERS
US President Donald Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin and China’s President Xi Jinping meet at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in Shenzhen, Guangdong province, on 18 November 2026.

Shenzhen: heavy on optics, light on substance

On 19 November, on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation Summit in Shenzhen, the leaders of the world’s three most powerful countries sat down under one roof for the first time since Roosevelt, Stalin, and Churchill met at Yalta in 1945. China’s state broadcaster China Central Television said the meeting between Xi Jinping, Vladimir Putin, and Donald Trump would “go down in history”. It was probably right. But what did it actually achieve?

Although their joint communiqué was called the ‘China-Russia-US Heads of State Declaration Toward Peace,’ it completely ignored the elephant in the room: Russia’s ongoing war with Ukraine and America’s ongoing war with Iran. As such, the Declaration speaks about peace only in the abstract, while glossing over anything that might demand immediate attention. So, was it just another photo opportunity? Does Beijing get the bragging rights for facilitating it?

China has no intention of going out on a limb to mediate peace in either Ukraine or Iran. Last month, German President Frank-Walter Steinmeier asked Xi if the trilateral summit would touch on the war in Ukraine. Xi appeared irritated, replying that it was a European war, so European countries should sit at the negotiating table. For Beijing, the risks of a failed mediation far outweigh the returns of a successful one.

Mediating is not just about convincing the warring parties to sit at the same negotiating table, something Trump spent two years trying to do. It also requires the mediator to enforce compliance. Inevitably, if bombing resumes, the mediator then takes the blame. In Chinese culture, the mediator would be said to have ‘lost face’.

Mediating peace in Ukraine or Iran is challenging since two of the warring parties are superpowers. Both wars have settled into stalemates, and none of the four warring parties are willing to negotiate in good faith. When all parties believe that time is on their side—or that just one more successful offensive on their part will break the stalemate—diplomacy can only go so far.

Beijing could bring the warring parties to the table, but whether they have the political will to negotiate is another matter. Rather than risk looking like a weak mediator, China prefers to keep the wars at arm's length and pass the issue (along with the blame) to others.

 Mark Schiefelbein / Reuters
US President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping react to musicians' performance as they walk to their luncheon at the Kylin Villa in Shenzhen in southern China’s Guangdong Province, on 19 November 2026.

A win for China, Russia and Trump

For Xi, the summit was an achievement in itself, one measured less by what it accomplished than by the fact that it took place at all. After years of strained relations between superpowers, bringing the trio to the same table was a feat in itself. And rather than pressing sensitive issues, Beijing decided a joint declaration glossing over their disagreements was preferable to none, and it knew this would happen only if everyone left with something they could present as a 'win' back home.

For Beijing, a summit held in China, hosted by China, and attended by the leaders of two of the world's most powerful countries, delivered a powerful message that the "great rejuvenation of the Chinese nation" is well underway, that the "century of humiliation" (when China suffered at the hands of the West and Japan) is in the rearview mirror, and that China is once again the "Middle Kingdom" (what China calls itself), having reclaimed its historic place at the centre of the world.

Russia is the weakest of the three great powers, so the summit gave it the opportunity to stand alongside China and the US as an equal

For Moscow, the summit was just as valuable, if not more so. Russia is the weakest of the three, so the summit gave it the opportunity to stand alongside China and the US as an equal. That symbolic parity alone is worth more to Russia than any substantive outcome.

For the White House, this was a useful tonic after the Democrats' landslide midterm victory. Donald Trump is keen to flex his foreign policy muscles before becoming a lame-duck president. To his credit, he secured the backing of both China and Russia on several of his priorities, no small feat for a man whose diplomatic experience had otherwise been marked by confrontation with Beijing and Moscow.

Trump wants the UN reformed, the International Criminal Court hobbled, and production of refined petroleum products increased, to help bring down pump prices at home. Although their joint declaration contained nothing concrete, it was enough for Trump to present it as a win domestically.

Reuters
As US President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping, and Russian President Vladimir Putin arrive for a trilateral meeting at the "Kelin" Villa in the Shenzhen, China on 19 November 2026.

Substantive results

The summit was not wholly without substance. Even before New START (the last US-Russia nuclear weapons reduction treaty) expired in February, Washington was pushing for a new agreement that included China, something Beijing resisted, arguing that its 600 warheads were far less than those of Russia and the US. China would join reduction talks, it said, only if those stockpiles were reduced to comparable levels.

Signs now suggest this standoff is easing. The joint declaration reaffirmed that a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought, and that the trio agreed to hold a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing the proliferation of nuclear weapons. Although it is not specific, it marks the first time that the three leaders have jointly addressed the issue.

Even if it remains unwilling to place its own stockpile on the table, Beijing's agreement to that statement is still a notable development, since it keeps the door open to talks on nuclear weapons reduction measures in the future. The international community should welcome this. Xi likened nuclear weapons to the Sword of Damocles hanging over humanity, saying they should be completely prohibited and destroyed over time. This is aspirational, not operational. Still, it leaves room for hope that the spectre of nuclear war will one day be a dark footnote in history.

font change