Europe's leaders take notes on Meloni's tough migration stance

At a time when so many European leaders are facing intense political pressure to resolve the migrant crisis, the Italian PM's ability to reduce illegal migration by 60% has turned heads

Migrants disembark from a lifeboat on the southeast coast of England after being picked up at sea while crossing the English Channel from France on August 16, 2023.
HENRY NICHOLLS / AFP
Migrants disembark from a lifeboat on the southeast coast of England after being picked up at sea while crossing the English Channel from France on August 16, 2023.

Europe's leaders take notes on Meloni's tough migration stance

At a time when Europe is struggling to cope with illegal migration, Italian Prime Minister Georgia Meloni's uncompromising approach to tackling the issue is generating widespread interest. The challenge of dealing with the large numbers of migrants seeking to make a better life for themselves in prosperous European countries is proving to be highly problematic for a number of prominent European leaders.

In Germany, the left-of-centre coalition headed by German Chancellor Olaf Scholz is under threat from the growing popularity of right-wing parties, such as the AfD, which made significant gains in recent regional elections in eastern Germany. For his part, French President Emmanuel Macron is facing a similar threat from Marine Le Pen’s National Rally, which came close to winning a parliamentary majority in recent elections.

Meanwhile, in the UK, the challenge posed by the wave of illegal migrants who continue to make the perilous crossing across the English Channel is proving to be just as much of a headache for the new Labour government headed by British Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer as it was for the previous Conservative administration.

One of Starmer’s first acts after winning July’s general election was to abandon the controversial Rwanda scheme devised by former Conservative Prime Minister Rishi Sunak, whereby migrants found to have entered the UK illegally would have been deported to the central African state. But having scrapped the previous British government’s plan to tackle the migrant issue, Starmer now finds himself under increasing pressure to come up with an alternative plan of his own, one that will be effective in ending the deadly cross-Channel migrant trade.

The scale of the problem facing the UK authorities was highlighted last weekend when more than 1,000 illegal migrants made their way across the English Channel to the UK, with the deaths of eight migrants, who died when their inflatable boat hit rocks off the French coast, highlighting the treacherous nature of the crossings.

Dan Kitwood/Getty
Inflatable dinghies and off-board motors believed to have been used by migrants to cross the English Channel from France to England are stored in a Home Office compound in Dover, England, on September 17, 2024.

With European leaders from London to Berlin desperate to find a solution to the issue, one that has the potential to cause them serious political damage, recent policies adopted by Italy have seen a significant reduction in the numbers of migrants making their way from North Africa to the Italian coast, are therefore attracting widespread attention.

Meloni’s success in becoming Italy’s prime minister in October 2022 owed much to her hard-line stand on the migration issue, with Italy struggling to cope with the boatloads of illegal migrants regularly travelling from countries such as Libya and Tunisia.

Her success, therefore, in implementing a range of policies that have resulted in the number of migrants travelling to Italy falling by 60% has impressed other European leaders, including Starmer, who travelled to Italy last week for his first face-to-face summit with the Italian premier.

Meloni’s success in tackling the migrant issue owes much to the support she has received from Ursula von der Leyen, the president of the European Commission, who oversaw the drafting of a European Union deal with Tunisia, whereby the North African country receives millions of euros to stop migrant boats from leaving, as well as investment in businesses and education aimed at deterring migration.

Meloni's success in reducing illegal migration by 60% has impressed Starmer, who travelled to Italy last week to meet her

The Tunisia deal, moreover, echoes a similar arrangement struck with Libya in 2017, which provides funding to equip and train the Libyan coastguard to stop people leaving from Libya's shoreline, which is also credited with reducing the flow of migrants.

As part of her personal mission to ensure the policies are implemented, Meloni has travelled to Tunisia and Libya this year to pressure their leaders to reinforce those pacts and curb irregular migration more dramatically. Her desire to tackle the issue intensified last September when more than 11,000 people arrived on the tiny Mediterranean island of Lampedusa, undermining her election campaign promise to curb migration.

Apart from lobbying North African countries to stem the flow of migrants, she also passed measures extending the amount of time people can be held in deportation detention centres to 18 months while ordering the construction of new centres. Italy also made a deal with Albania under which men arriving on boats from North Africa would be taken to centres in the neighbouring country to have their asylum claims processed.

Another controversial move by the Meloni government has been to impose measures against charity ships operating in the Mediterranean, with captains facing huge fines if they carry out more than one rescue operation at a time.

Filippo MONTEFORTE / AFP
Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni and British Prime Minister Keir Starmer walk in the garden of Villa Doria Pamphili after their meeting on September 16, 2024 in Rome.

While Meloni's approach has attracted criticism, not lease from humanitarian groups, the success Italy has achieved in reducing the flow of migrants has impressed a number of European leaders, who are keen to explore the possibility of adopting similar measures.

The main purpose of Starmer's recent visit to Italy was to see if similar measures could be used to stem the flow of Channel crossings, even though his desire to forge a closer relationship with the right-wing Meloni has attracted criticism from left-wing politicians in the UK. During his visit, Starmer, the head of the UK's left-of-centre Labour party, heaped praise on Meloni, congratulating her on making "remarkable progress" in tackling migration.

Whether Meloni's uncompromising approach can work for the new British government, though, remains to be seen, especially as the British prime minister's overtures to the Italian premier have already drawn criticism from some of his Labour backbenchers. One of his more forthright critics was the hard-left Labour MP Diane Abbott, who tweeted, "Why is Starmer meeting with Italian PM Giorgia Meloni, a literal fascist, to discuss immigration? What does he hope to learn from her?"

Another Labour MP, Kim Johnson, told the Guardian newspaper that it was "disturbing" to see Starmer seeking to learn lessons from Italy. Even so, at a time when so many European leaders are facing intense political pressure to resolve the migrant crisis, the tangible success Meloni has enjoyed with her approach will give them serious food for thought as they assess how to deal with their own domestic challenges.

font change

Related Articles