War has hurt Israel's economy but devastated Lebanon's

Both countries have suffered massive economic blows. But Lebanon's economy was already on its knees before the war, making recovery and reconstruction all the more difficult.

A man inspects the rubble of a house destroyed in Israeli bombardment in the southern Lebanese village of Kfar Kila.
Hassan FNEICH / AFP
A man inspects the rubble of a house destroyed in Israeli bombardment in the southern Lebanese village of Kfar Kila.

War has hurt Israel's economy but devastated Lebanon's

For decades, the Lebanese economy has been battered by wars and invasions, but the financial fallout and social damage from Hezbollah’s current battle with Israel is set to leave the biggest scar of all.

In large part, this is due to the timing. Israel’s large-scale bombing of Lebanon this week only adds to the country’s accumulated losses from decades of conflict followed by its complete financial collapse in 2019.

The cross-border fighting covers a productive area. The Lebanon-Israel border stretches for 81km from the coastal city of Naqoura to Mount Hermon, encompassing numerous villages and towns plus hundreds of thousands of hectares of fertile land. For Lebanon to lose this land or the productive use of it would be disastrous, but the shelling in recent weeks has expanded rapidly, and the old ‘rules of engagement’ seem to have been thrown out the window.

It is too early to calculate the growing losses for both the Lebanese and Israeli economies or to provide any accurate assessment of the effects and consequences of fighting that began almost a year ago, on 8 October 2023, but both sides are clearly hurting.

Lebanese losses

Hezbollah members and leaders have been injured and killed, whether by exploding communication devices or by drone strikes, yet the group’s losses pale in comparison to the losses that Lebanon has been left counting. Although some rockets have been fired into northern Israel, the level of damage and destruction is disproportionately larger on the Lebanese side due to the immense firepower of the Israeli army. Some villages in south Lebanon have been all but destroyed.

In Lebanon, daily losses from closed businesses are conservatively estimated at around $10m, while direct and indirect damage from Israeli air raids is estimated at $7bn. As the bombing continues, this figure will climb.

Nearly half a million Lebanese from the south and Beirut's southern suburbs have been displaced, finding shelter in schools, community centres, or rented homes. Many wonder what they will return to.

AFP
An injured child poses for a picture at a school in Beirut housing displaced people who fled Israeli strikes in southern Lebanon on September 26, 2024.

More than 6,000 acres of agricultural land have been scorched by Israeli phosphorus (the use of which is banned internationally). Lebanon's agriculture minister, Abbas Al-Haj Hassan, told Al Majalla that the Israeli assault has severely damaged southern Lebanon. Over 60,000 olive trees have been burned (some were over 300 years old), while thousands of hectares of vegetation have been destroyed.

Agriculture in the south normally constitutes 30% of Lebanese agricultural output, but this has now all but halted. More than 10,000 homes have been partially or completely destroyed, as have around 3,500 industrial or agricultural units.

Schools across Lebanon have closed. Hospitals require additional funding. Tourists have disappeared, as have foreign expatriates. The money that the central bank and government relied on to support currency stability may soon vanish.

Israeli losses

Israeli losses are also mounting. Government sources estimate total losses at around $20bn, which includes reconstruction costs. Israel's economy is around 30 times the size of Lebanon's, which magnifies the losses.

In addition, many Israeli industrial groups are concentrated in northern Israel, near the Lebanese border, and they have been forced to close as the fighting intensifies. Further costs come from the Israeli government's commitment to cover all war-related expenses, including military and logistical needs, compensation, and housing aid for around 200,000 Israelis displaced from northern villages and settlements.

In Lebanon, direct and indirect damage from Israeli air raids is estimated at $7bn and will rise as the war rages on

Israeli economist and advisor to the prime minister, Yacov Sheinin, said the total cost could reach $120bn, which is roughly 20% of Israel's gross domestic product (GDP). To cover costs, Israel's government has increased taxes and borrowing, which will increase debt servicing costs and inflation, slowing production and growth. Officials acknowledge that Israel's ability to attract both money and people has been affected.

Israel's 2024 government spending is due to hit $160bn, raising the budget deficit to 6.6% of GDP, according to Israeli websites. The Ministry of Finance said the war in Gaza and Lebanon had doubled Israel's debt and increased inflation in 2023.

Although Israel's economy grew by 2% annually, this turned negative in the last quarter of 2023 after the war in Gaza began. Israel's long-term credit rating was later downgraded (from AA- to A+) by Standard & Poor's (S&P).

Companies have closed due to the prolonged call-up of hundreds of thousands of reservists. "No sector is immune to the effects of the war," said Yoel Amir of business intelligence group CofaceBdi, speaking to The Times of Israel.

"Companies are dealing with a very complex reality, such as staff shortages, falling demand, increased financing needs, increased purchasing costs, logistical issues and, most recently, an export ban by Turkey," he said.

"This makes it difficult for them to continue production during this period… A large percentage have been forced to close since the beginning of the war, around 35,000. Small companies are the most vulnerable because they have the most financing needs."

Israel's total losses hover at $20bn. Its economy is around 30 times the size of Lebanon's, which magnifies the losses.

The tech sector has been particularly affected, with a reported 56% decline in performance as of June 2024, according to Bloomberg. Almost half the major Israeli tech companies reported losses due to the war.

Rating agencies like Fitch and S&P say the war has halted more than $15bn worth of investments in Israel, which is known as "the start-up nation" for its record of innovation. A report by Startup Nation Central in September found that 48% of investors think their Israeli tech shares will decline in the coming months.

Tourism in Israel has also been hit, with the number of tourists dropping from 300,000 per month during the non-war months of 2023 to less than 80,000 per month from November 2023 to March 2024. This has led to economic damage, including pulled investment and job losses.

According to the economic newspaper Globes, Israeli agriculture has also suffered. This sector used to account for 5% of Israel's GDP and employ around one in ten workers. Yet, just in June of this year, the sector is estimated to have lost around $360m.

There are big costs associated with temporarily re-homing Israelis living near the northern border with Lebanon, with many having to stay in hotels. Ensuring their safety to return home is now an official Israeli war aim.

Many now ask: at what cost?

font change

Related Articles