Turks vote in crucial and symbolic election

It is the single most important election since the first multi-party election was held in 1946, and also comes on the 100th anniversary of the Turkish Republic

The incumbent party of Erdoğan, the AKP, seems to have lost momentum, but it is still premature to make any definitive predictions at this stage.
Ewan-White
The incumbent party of Erdoğan, the AKP, seems to have lost momentum, but it is still premature to make any definitive predictions at this stage.

Turks vote in crucial and symbolic election

Turkish citizens are heading to the polls today to vote in presidential and parliamentary elections, which is probably the single most important election since the first multi-party election was held in 1946.

As 2023 is the year which marks the 100th anniversary of the Republic of Turkey, the results will have symbolic value.

The Justice and Development Party (AKP) has been in power since 2002. Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has ruled as prime minister (2003 to 2014) and as president (2014-present).

During his term as prime minister, Erdoğan argued that the incumbent political establishment slowed down progress in Turkey and called for a new Turkey in a campaign that he dubbed “Turkey’s century”.

The coup d'etat attempt in 2016 provided Erdoğan with an opportunity to push forward his idea to change the system. In April 2017, a referendum was held to vote on amendments to the constitution, enabling the system change, proposed by AKP and its ally Nationalist Action Party (MHP).

Erdoğan got what he wanted with 25,157,463 (51.41%) “yes” votes to 23,779,141 (48.59%) “no” votes.

As a result, the office of the prime minister was abolished and replaced with a presidential system and executive presidency, where the president is elected every five years.

The first presidential election under the new system in 2018

The presidential election is a two-round system. If no candidate is able to cross the “50% plus one” threshold, two candidates with the highest votes compete in a run-off.

Six candidates ran for the presidential post in 2018. Erdoğan won in the first round with 52.59% of votes, becoming the first president of the new system. His closest contender, Muharrem İnce of the Republican Peoples Party (CHP) received 30.64%.

Diana Estafana Rubio

Municipal election in March 2019

The last time Turkish voters went to the polls was in March 2019 for municipal elections. The results were a disappointment for Erdoğan and had a major political impact on Turkish politics.

AKP lost the municipalities of major cities of Istanbul, Ankara, Bolu and Antalya, which it had held for the last 20 or more years under other party banners.

CHP took over these cities and two star figures entered onto the Turkish political stage: Ekrem İmamoğlu (CHP), new Mayor of Istanbul and Mansur Yavaş (CHP), new Mayor of Ankara.

Upcoming parliamentary election

According to the Supreme Election Council, 60,904,499 people are eligible to vote in a total of 190,736 voting centres.

Another 3,286,786 are eligible to vote abroad, in 4,969 voting centres established in 74 countries. These are Turks living abroad, with the majority in Germany, and also in big numbers in France, United Kingdom, Netherlands and Austria.

Thirty-six political parties have qualified to participate in the elections but four will be participating within the lists of other political parties and thus, names and logos of 32 parties will appear on the ballot papers.

There are 87 constituencies, and each constituency has a certain number of parliamentarians depending on the population. In total, there are 600 parliamentarians and İstanbul is the constituent with the greatest number of representatives, with 98.

As a result of 2018 elections, distribution of parliamentarians in İstanbul was as follows: AKP 43, CHP 27, HDP 11, İYİP 8, MHP 8, TİP 1.

Ewan-White

The D’Hondt method is used in calculating the number of parliamentarians.

Calculation and distribution of deputies in the electoral districts will be determined by considering the number of votes received by each party within the alliance in that electoral district. The votes cast abroad are added proportionally to the votes the parties receive across the country.

The election threshold in Turkey was 10%, which was considered too high for fair democratic representation. In March 2022, it was brought down to 7%, which is an improvement but still high compared to an average of 5% in democracies across the globe.

The election threshold in Turkey was 10%, which was considered too high for fair democratic representation. In March 2022, it was brought down to 7%, which is an improvement but still high compared to an average of 5% in democracies across the globe. 

One of the arguments Erdoğan used in favour of changing the old system was that it produced coalition governments which had many defects. With the presidential system, coalitions are no longer, but they have been replaced by "alliances". Thus, the name may have changed but the essence remains the same.

The election threshold of 7% applies to individual political parties and alliances. If the total number of votes of an alliance exceeds it, all the parties forming the coalition are considered to have passed.

Major political parties

  • Justice and Development Party (Adalet ve Kalkınma Partisi/AKP): right, conservative, led by President Erdoğan.
  • Grand Unity Party (Büyük Birlik Partisi): ultra nationalist-conservative.
  • People's Republican Party (Cumhuriyet Halk Partisi/CHP): centre left/social democrat.
  • Democrat Party (Demokrat Parti/DP): centre right
  • Democracy and Progress Party (DEVA): liberal conservative
  • Future Party (Gelecek Partisi): right, conservative
  • Green Left Party (Yeşil Sol Parti/YSP): left, will run in the elections replacing Peoples' Democratic Party (HDP) which did not want to risk closure
  • Free Cause Party (Hüdapar): ultra-religious
  • Good Party (İyi Party/İYİP): centre right/nationalist
  • Homeland Party (Memleket Partisi): centre left/nationalist
  • Nationalist Action Party (Milliyetçi Hareket Partisi/MHP): ultra nationalist with a taste of Erdogan and conservatism
  • Felicity Party (Saadet Partisi): conservative/religious.
  • Workers Party of Turkey (Türkiye İşçi Partisi/TİP): socialist
  • Patriotic Party (Vatan Partisi/VP): left, EuroAsianist
  • New Welfare Party (Yeniden Refah Partisi): religious
  • Victory Party (Zafer Partisi): far right, Turkish nationalist, anti-immigration

Major alliances

Political parties within alliances will either enter the election with their own candidate lists (separate lists) under their own logo or with joint lists as part of a strategy. Traditional strongholds of political parties as well as candidates are among factors.

On 10 April, political parties presented their lists to the candidates to the Supreme Election Council.

"People's Alliance" (Cumhur İttifakı)

Presidential candidate: Recep Tayyip Erdoğan

Political parties in the alliance:

  • Justice and Development Party (AKP): right, conservative/nationalist
  • Grand Unity Party (BBP): ultra nationalist-conservative
  • Nationalist Action Party (MHP): ultra nationalist with a taste of conservatism
  • New Welfare Party (RP): religious right
  • Free Cause Party (HüdaPar)
  • Democratic Left Party (DSP)

AKP, MHP, BBP and RP will each enter the election with its own list.

Hüdapar (4) and DSP (3) candidates will be included in AKP list. The leaders of these parties have been placed in districts in Istanbul where, normally, they would be elected.

"Nation Alliance" (Millet İttifakı) also known as "Table of 6"

Presidential candidate: Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu

Political parties in the alliance:

  • Republican People's Party (CHP): centre left/social democrat
  • Democrat Party (DP): centre right
  • Democracy and Progress Party (DEVA): liberal conservative
  • Future Party (GP): right, conservative
  • Good Party (İYİP): centre right/nationalist
  • Felicity Party (SP): religious, conservative

In the Nation Alliance, it is a little bit more complicated as 77 candidates from six parties outside of CHP will enter elections from CHP lists. The distribution is; DEVA (25), SP (24), GP (19) and DP (3) candidates. A former deputy from CHP, who later resigned and formed his own party, Party of Change, has also been included in CHP list.

The second largest party of Nation Alliance, İYİP, will enter the elections with its own list but they have agreed to coordinate with CHP in places where they can win more if their votes are added together.

Using this strategy, CHP will not enter elections in 7 and İYİP in 9 electoral constituencies. Also, İYİP will have five of its candidates enter from CHP lists.

"Labour and Freedom Alliance" (Emek ve Özgürlük İttifakı)

No Presidential candidate

Political parties in the alliance:

  • Green Left Party (YSP), labelled as the party of Kurds, will enter the elections as the backup party of Peoples' Democratic Party (HDP) against the risk of its closure
  • Workers Party of Turkey (TİP): socialist
  • Four very small leftist/socialist parties

TİP will participate in the election with its own separate list in 41 electoral constituencies.

Candidates of HDP and four left parties will participate in a joint list.

"Ata Alliance" (Ata İttifakı)

Presidential candidate: Sinan Ogan

Political parties in the alliance:

  • Victory Party (ZP) and three miniscule parties: far right, Turkish nationalist, anti-immigration.

All candidates will be included in the list of Victory Party.

Women representation

People's Alliance:

  • AKP: 113 out of 600 candidates (18.83%)
  • MHP: 90 out of 600 candidates (14%)
  • SP: 45 out of 600 candidates (7.5%)

Nation Alliance:

  • CHP: 156 out of 582 candidates (26.80%)
  • İYİP: 139 out of 536 candidates (25.9%)

Labour and Freedom Alliance:

  • GLP: 193 out of 490 candidates (39.38%)
  • TİP: 161 out of 398 candidates (40.45%)

Maverick parties

İYİP is founded by breakaways from MHP, led by Meral Aksener. She is the sole female leader on the present Turkish political stage.    

Future Party (GP) is founded by Ahmet Davutoğlu, former Minister of Foreign Affairs and prime minister, who broke away from AKP.

Ali Babacan, former economy minister and deputy prime minister also broke away from AKP and established DEVA.

The Homeland Party (MP) is founded by Muharrem Ince, who was the candidate for CHP for presidency in 2018 and who later resigned after losing against Erdoğan.

The Peoples' Democratic Party (HDP) — which faces terrorism-related charges and in order to avoid the risk of not being able to participate in elections in case of a closure — will run as another party, the Green Left Party (YSP).

It is the so-called Kurds' party with an estimated support of 9 to 12%. Note that YSP's support base is not limited to Kurds, nor all Kurds vote for it. Selahattin Demirtas, the party's former co-chair and a popular politician, has been in prison since November 2016 on "terror-related charges". 

Meanwhile, the Workers Party of Turkey (TİP) may be the rising star of the elections. It has four members in the present parliament and their dynamism has been appreciated even by those who are ideologically on the opposite side. The polls indicate that their support rate is around 2.8%. 

The Workers Party of Turkey (TİP) may be the rising star of the elections. It has four members in the present parliament and their dynamism has been appreciated even by those who are ideologically on the opposite side. The polls indicate that their support rate is around 2.8%.

The Victory Party (ZP), led by Ümit Özdağ, is on the far right, and is Turkish nationalist. Its foundations are based on anti-immigration. It represents people who wants Syrians and other groups like Afghans sent back to their countries. At first, the party was the centre of attention but lately its popularity is waning.

The religious Welfare Party (RP) is led by Fatih Erbakan — the son of a very famous conservative politician and the founder of the party. When Erbakan was called upon by AKP to join the People's Alliance, he went on record by saying: "We cannot be a partner in 20 years of sin. The AKP party has come to an end."

Despite this clear statement, shortly after, the same Erbakan withdrew his candidacy for presidency and announced that his party had now decided to enter elections with AKP and the People's Alliance

Hüdapar is ultra-religious, openly anti-secular and anti-Republican. It is said to be connected to what is called Turkish Hezbollah which is responsible for a number of political/ideological murders. 

Hüdapar is more in the picture in the south-east of Turkey and its members are mostly ultra-religious Kurds. It received 0.31% of the vote in the 2018 elections.

Presidential election

The current presidential term is five years, and a candidate may be elected for a maximum of two terms.  

Presidential candidates are either nominated by a political party/alliance or enter the race as independents. Any eligible person who is able to collect 100,000 signatures from the public can run as an independent candidate.

If none of the candidates are able to get "50% plus one vote", the second round will take place 14 days later, on 28 March. With that system, every vote is important and all political parties, no matter how small they are, count.

There are four presidential candidates:

  • Recep Tayyip Erdoğan (People's Alliance)
  • Muharrem Ince (Victory Party)
  • Kemal Kılıcdaroglu (Nation Alliance)
  • Sinan Ogan (Ata Alliance)

About the candidates:

Recep Tayyip Erdoğan

Ewan-White
Recep Tayyip Erdogan

  • Born in 1954
  • Conservative, populist
  • Mayor of Istanbul from 1994 to 1998
  • One of the main founders of AKP in 2001
  • Leader of the Party since 2003
  • He has been ruling the country for the last 20 years as prime minister (2003-2014) and president (2014-present)

Kemal Kılıcdaroglu

Ewan-White
Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu

  • Born in 1948
  • Social democrat
  • Before entering politics a civil servant, served as the president of the Social Insurance Institution.
  • He was elected to parliament in 2002
  • Leader of CHP since 2010

Muharrem İnce

Ewan-White
Muharrem Ince

  • Born in 1964
  • Social democrat
  • Physics teacher and school principal
  • Served as member of parliament for CHP until he resigned in 2018
  • He was the presidential candidate for CHP in 2018 elections and came in second after Erdoğan
  • He founded the Homeland party in 2021

Sinan Ogan

Ewan-White

  • Born in 1967
  • Nationalist
  • Academician-strategist
  • He was a member of parliament for MHP
  • He left his party over disagreements with its leadership

Erdoğan's main challenger is Kılıçdaroğlu. The two men have completely different characters and styles. Erdoğan is charismatic, assertive, always ready for a fight while Kılıçdaroğlu is soft spoken and appears to prefer consensus rule. 

Erdoğan is charismatic, assertive, always ready for a fight while Kılıçdaroğlu is soft spoken and appears to prefer consensus rule. 

Ewan-White

Read more: Erdoğan and Kılıçdaroğlu face off in tight race for Turkish presidency

Neither HDP and TİP are fielding a candidate and are both expected to back Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu in the presidential race.

Opposition voters are concerned that Muharrem İnce will attract some of the very much needed votes from CHP. Some go so far to claim that Erdoğan supporting İnce's party and candidacy behind the scenes exactly for this reason.

İnce claims his support in the first round to be around 10%. He further claims that he is the only candidate who could defeat Erdoğan in a second round.

Ince is upset for being sidelined by CHP and seems to have made a personal issue out of it. But in politics everything is possible and İnce may have a last-minute change of heart in favour of Kılıcdaroğlu.

Polling data as of 10 April 2023

  • Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu:  48.3%
  • Recep Tayyip Erdoğan: 43.8%
  • Muharrem İnce: 5.5%
  • Sinan Oğan:  2.2%

Kılıçdaroğlu appears to be leading in most polls, but as no candidate is able to reach "50 % plus one", a second round seems inevitable.

What about vice-presidents?

In Turkey, unlike in the United States, vice-presidents do not run in the elections. The president may appoint one or more vice-presidents after being elected.

In the event that the office of the president becomes vacant for any reason, the election of the president is held within 45 days. Until then, the vice-president exercises the powers of the president.

When Erdoğan was elected in 2018, he appointed Fuat Oktay, former undersecretary of the prime ministry, as vice-president. This time again, it is not known who or how many vice-presidents Erdoğan may appoint if he wins.

If Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu is elected, part of the Nation Alliance deal is that the leaders of the other five parties in the alliance plus the mayors of Ankara and İstanbul will serve as vice-presidents — much like a board of directors who would report to the president.

Key election issues

"We expanded our economy, strengthened our democracy, eliminated bans and gave self-confidence and credibility to Turkish foreign policy," Erdoğan has claimed.

But not everyone agrees.

The opposition argues that in all these areas, Turkey under Erdoğan went backward. There are so many issues on the political agenda, but the following are at the top of the list.

Earthquake recovery: The 6 February earthquake hit 11 provinces with massive human loss and damage. Officially, as of 10 April, 50,399 people lost their lives in the tragedy.

The Minister of Environment and Urbanisation has stated that 227,027 buildings fall into the category of "to be demolished urgently, heavily damaged or collapsed". A massive recovery, rehabilitation and reconstruction effort is underway. Difficulties and challenges are many.

Eduardo Ramon

Read more: Sifting through the rubble and political fallout of Turkey's quake

Economy: The government has been troubled by economic conditions for some time now. The annual inflation rate is 57.68%. Actual figures are, almost for sure, well beyond the official numbers. The inflation rate for food prices is 187% for the last two years, even though it has decreased globally.

Unemployment stands at 9.7%. National income per capita has remained stagnant for years. Meanwhile, the Turkish Lira has lost value against foreign currencies and the majority of Turkish people are poorer. 

National income per capita has remained stagnant for years. Meanwhile, the Turkish Lira has lost value against foreign currencies and the majority of Turkish people are poorer. 

On its part, the government claims that the economy is doing very well and anything negative is caused by global conditions and the earthquake. The opposition recognises the difficulties created by these factors but puts the bulk of the blame on government policies.

Security: Activities of the PKK in Turkey have been curbed to a large extent. Several of its leading members have been killed or captured. But the problem still remains, and Syria and Iraq add an additional dimension to the problem. 

Return of Syrians and others: There are more than 4.5 million Syrians and Afghans in Turkey. Many Turks are of the opinion that it is time for them to return home. This is one of the hottest issues for the electorate.

Foreign Policy: The government is trying to show that Turkey is doing well on the international stage. There have been some so-called successes but overall, things are not as rosy as the government portrays.

Just to cite a few examples; rapprochement efforts with the al-Assad regime in Syria have not moved in the government's favour, at least as of today.

Meanwhile, relations with the European Union are frozen. President Biden, once again, has not invited Turkey  to the Summit for Democracy. Also, the sale of F-16 fighter jets and modernisation kits has not been realised even though the US administration says it supports the sale.

Latest polls

According to latest election polls of 11 polling companies in March 2023, average votes of the parties are indicated as follows:

Diana Estafana Rubio

Meanwhile, AKP polls sing a different tune. The deputy chairman of the party said that according to the latest survey conducted by their teams, Erdoğan's vote is 53% whereas AKP's is 41% and climbing.   In any case, the objective view is that AKP has lost momentum, but it is still premature to make any definitive predictions at this stage.

The opposition is concerned about election rigging. It argues that even if Erdoğan loses, he will not let go easily, as he and his entourage have a lot to lose.

Read more: With a lot to lose, Erdoğan canvases for votes with grand gestures

Likely scenarios

Turkey is moving with full speed toward an election with very deep divides between opposing sides on almost every issue.

Three most likely possibilities at the end of the elections are:

  • Erdoğan wins presidency, wins majority in parliament
  • Erdoğan wins presidency, loses majority in parliament
  • Erdoğan loses presidency, loses majority in parliament

Erdoğan is regarded by many in Turkey and abroad as increasingly authoritarian. His tenure in office — especially in the last few years — has been mired in crises, allegations of corruption and dire economic conditions.

He still has his die-hard supporters. His personal popularity appears to outweigh that of his party's, but despite that, it looks like it has declined nonetheless.

Ewan-White

Erdoğan and his supporters point out that Turkey is on the precipice of greatness, claiming only they can manage it.

Erdoğan has launched his campaign under the slogan "Century of Turkey" and has introduced his election manifesto which includes a new civilian constitution, disaster-resilient cities, reforms that strengthen the rule of law, reduced inflation and further development of humanitarian and conscientious foreign policy.

The opposition Nation Alliance, on the other hand, is moving forward with a pledge to bring back justice, end corruption, fix the economy and make Turkey trustworthy again.

Kılıcdaroglu has emphasised that everything will need to be restored, and one of his top priorities will be to reinstate state structures which have been damaged by AKP's partisan policies.

While it remains unclear who will win, what is certain is that the victor will have a full plate of issues to deal with.

font change

Related Articles