Israel’s ‘voluntary’ migration policy in Gaza is anything but

Palestinians are beginning to dribble out of the battered enclave as Israel starts implementing its "voluntary migration" plan. Gaza is being ethnically cleansed before our very eyes.

Israel forcibly evacuates Palestinians from southern Gaza on January 26, 2024.
AFP
Israel forcibly evacuates Palestinians from southern Gaza on January 26, 2024.

Israel’s ‘voluntary’ migration policy in Gaza is anything but

Israel’s newly established Migration Directorate is already working to change the future of Gaza in an attempt to derail Arab efforts against its ethnic cleansing.

The directorate is an affiliate of Israel’s Ministry of Defence and was unveiled by Defence Minister Israel Katz in mid-February after he ordered his army to formulate a plan to help Palestinians leave Gaza if they so wish.

Israel describes this as a “voluntary migration” to other countries where Palestinians would permanently resettle. This matches up with US President Donald Trump’s plan for building a “Middle East Riviera” in the Gaza Strip.

Despite vehement Arab opposition, Israel is firmly in favour, with Katz describing it as “bold”. The Coordinator of Government Activities in the Territories (COGAT), another Ministry of Defence unit, is facilitating logistical coordination between Israel and Gaza, securing the departure of residents.

It has already arranged for the departure of 100 Gaza residents to Indonesia, where they will work in construction under a pilot programme that Israel hopes will provide a model and encourage other Palestinians to leave, with the Migration Directorate facilitating their exit.

Omar AL-QATTAA / AFP
People erect tents amidst the rubble of destroyed buildings as displaced Palestinians return to the northern areas of the Gaza Strip in Jabalia on January 23, 2025, during a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas was reached.

Reasons to leave

The Gaza Strip has been decimated. In February, a joint report by the United Nations, the World Bank, and the European Union put infrastructure damage at $30bn and economic and social damage at $20bn.

In 2024, it said more than 292,000 homes had been destroyed or damaged, 95% of hospitals rendered non-functional, and the Strip’s economy had contracted by around 85%. Prices of goods (where available) had more than tripled, with unemployment at more than 80%. The percentage of the population in Gaza living in multi-dimensional poverty is due to hit 97.9%.

In opening the door for Palestinians to leave, Israel preys on their instinct to survive. It also knows that with most of its coastal territory destroyed, it is no longer fit for human habitation—a point Trump has emphasised multiple times in comments to the media.

Reinforcing message

Israel's resumption of the bombing just reinforces a message it has been trying to drive home: that nothing in Gaza will be left after it has finished. If that message wasn't clear enough, it has also blocked all entry of humanitarian aid and cut off water and electricity. For more than three weeks, nothing has gotten into Gaza—the longest period it has gone without aid since Israel launched its destructive war on 7 October.

Trump's real estate plan for Gaza jolted the Arab world into devising a Gaza reconstruction plan, endorsed by Arab leaders at an emergency summit in Egypt on 4 March. Despite being light on specifics, it intended to ward off Trump's blueprint.

Cairo is the driver behind the Arab plan. It has successfully rallied the international community behind it, but $53bn is still needed for its implementation. Next month, Egypt will host an international conference on Gaza's reconstruction, during which it will seek secure pledges of financial support.

Despite Trump singling out Egypt and Jordan to take in Palestinians from Gaza, both balked. For its part, Egypt has taken measures to prevent the displacement of the Palestinians into the Sinai Peninsula, increasing its security and military presence there.

This has led to accusations by some Israeli diplomats, including Israel's new ambassador to the US, that Cairo is violating the terms of their 1979 peace treaty, which limits Egyptian deployments in the region. Yet, Egypt's minister of defence has continually underscored the army's combat readiness and its ability to defend Egypt's borders.

Palestinians who escape death face hunger, malnutrition, disease and possibly a lifetime of psychological trauma

Closed Egyptian doors

On 4 March, Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi alluded to possible infringements of the peace treaty (the first between an Arab country and Israel) if either forced people into the territory of the other. He has vehemently rejected the displacement of Gaza's population of 2.2 million into the Sinai, which may have prompted a rethink in Tel Aviv.

Few in Israel now talk about displacing the Palestinians of Gaza into the Sinai since Israel gains nothing by irking Egypt. Cairo has now doubled down on its efforts to restore the ceasefire and improve living conditions where the UN has reported that more than 96% of Gaza's children and women cannot meet minimum dietary requirements, adding that "the collapse of local agricultural production threatens extended famine conditions" in Gaza.

"At least 111,000 have been injured and over 2 million people, almost the entire population in Gaza, have been uprooted from their homes," it says, adding that Palestinians "are facing acute shortages of all necessities" and are also experiencing hunger, malnutrition and risk injury from widespread explosive ordnance (EO) and illness from disease outbreaks.

This is also a population that has suffered massive psychological trauma, one that is ongoing, as Israeli jets and drones continue to strike Gaza's remaining mosques, hospitals, UN centres, and homes. The mental scars of those who survive the bombardment will last a lifetime. 

BASHAR TALEB / AFP
A Palestinian man hugs the body of a baby following Israeli overnight airstrikes in the northern Gaza Strip, at the Indonesian Hospital in Beit Lahia, on March 20, 2025.

Grim reality

In the midst of this grim reality, Palestinians cannot be blamed for seeking safety and a semblance of a future elsewhere. If some choose to leave, it is certainly not "voluntary" when they are forced to choose between death and misery or migration.

Apart from the 100 Palestinians in Gaza who left for Indonesia on 25 March, another 600 were scheduled to leave in the following few days. Earlier in March, some 1,000 left, adding to the 35,000 who have permanently departed since October 2023, according to Israeli media. 

These small successes will energise the Migration Directorate to coordinate the "voluntary migration" of Palestinians from their land, though it may take years to do so. If they are incentivised enough, some Arab states may end up reluctantly accepting Palestinians.

But some—or even many Palestinians—may choose to stand their ground, despite the apocalyptic conditions Israel has imposed on Gaza.  

Like everyone, Palestinians just want to live in peace and safety, yet they are now stuck in the middle of a bloody geopolitical struggle for the future of their territory. Their decisions over the coming weeks and months—to stay or leave—will determine whether Gaza remains part of an aspirational Palestinian state. But if they choose to go, it certainly won't be "voluntarily".

font change

Related Articles