Trump will have to contend with a much-changed Middle East

Trump will need to navigate a far more complex regional landscape, which comes with a unique set of challenges but also unique opportunities to shape a more prosperous region for the coming generations

Trump will have to contend with a much-changed Middle East

President Donald Trump will soon find out that the Middle East he knew in his first term has profoundly changed: Hamas launched a deadly attack on Israel on 7 October 2023, which had huge knock-on effects across the region, including the decapitation of Hezbollah's top leadership and the fall of the Syrian regime of Bashar al-Assad.

However, he will also understand that, as US president, he knows he holds the power to affect even more change. This was clearly demonstrated through his instrumental role in pressuring the warring parties in Gaza—Hamas and Israel—to finally agree to a ceasefire following 15 months of devastating war and back-and-forth negotiations.

Trump's warning that "all hell would break loose" if a deal wasn't reached before his inauguration seemed to have its intended effect—neither Hamas nor Israel dared to test the seriousness of his threat, given his highly unpredictable nature.

As the shake truce seems to be holding, Trump's next challenge will be in two weeks, when his administration will need to get Hamas and Israel back to the table to start negotiating the second phase of the agreement, scheduled to begin 42 days after the initial phase. This phase would see a full prisoner exchange, Israel's withdrawal from Gaza and a permanent ceasefire take hold.

Trump will find a drastically changed Middle East landscape, but as US president, he has the power to change it further

Palestinian state recognition?

Here, political negotiations—not just security-focused talks—are key to finding a lasting solution to the Israel-Palestine issue. If they follow the framework of the Saudi-led international initiative for a two-state solution, then things could progress more rapidly than many could imagine and even lead to international recognition of a Palestinian state. 

This could strengthen regional ties and pave the way for a reimagined Middle East—a landscape Trump has been keen to reshape as a part of his broader ambition to cement his legacy. He wants to be known as a peacemaker in both Ukraine and the Middle East, and he wants a Nobel Peace Prize.

Iran and Türkiye

As for Iran, Trump's strategy could oscillate between the "maximum pressure" policies he enacted during his first term in office, which could involve giving Netanyahu the green light for a decisive strike on Iran's nuclear programme, and exploring the possibility of clinching a deal with a weakened Iran—one that would be in America's favour and fit into his broader vision for the Middle East.

And while Iran has been weakened, Türkiye has expanded its influence in Syria and the wider region. Trump's close relationship with Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has heightened concerns among Syrian Kurds, who fear a repeat of the 2019 "betrayal" when Trump's decision to withdraw US troops from the eastern Euphrates paved the way for Turkish incursions, fragmenting the Kurdish entity east of Euphrates.

Despite Trump's stated priorities in Ukraine and China, the Middle East will continue to feature high on his agenda

More complex region

When Trump left office four years ago, the Middle East was defined by the Abraham Accords and pronounced regional divisions. On his return, he will encounter a region shaped by Arab-Arab, Arab-Turkish, and Arab-Iranian interactions, highlighting new alignments formed in the aftermath of major conflicts in Syria, Lebanon, and Gaza.

This is only part of the picture. There is another dimension to the Middle East. In the Gulf, an economic renaissance is unfolding, driven by Riyadh's ambitious reforms under Vision 2030, which have achieved significant progress. Saudi Arabia has hosted Arab and Islamic summits and taken a leading role in addressing critical issues—from Syria and Palestine to Sudan—where a civil war that erupted in April 2023 continues unabated.

Trump will need to navigate this new and far more complex regional landscape, which comes with a unique set of challenges but also unique opportunities to shape a new Middle East for the coming generations. And despite Trump's stated priorities in Ukraine and China, the Middle East will continue to feature high on his agenda.

font change