79 years ago, FDR made a promise to King Abdulaziz on Palestine

Ahead of a possible US-Saudi defence agreement, it is worth remembering Roosevelt reassured the Saudi king over Palestine, only for Truman to renege on it two years later.

King Abdul Aziz Al Saud of Saudi Arabia (1875 - 1953) (centre) and US President Franklin D Roosevelt (1882 - 1945) aboard the USS Quincy in Great Bitter Lake, Egypt February 14, 1945.
King Abdul Aziz Al Saud of Saudi Arabia (1875 - 1953) (centre) and US President Franklin D Roosevelt (1882 - 1945) aboard the USS Quincy in Great Bitter Lake, Egypt February 14, 1945.

79 years ago, FDR made a promise to King Abdulaziz on Palestine

On 14 February 1945, a historic meeting was convened onboard an American destroyer in the Suez Canal between King Abdulaziz Al Saud, founder of the modern Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, and US President Franklin D. Roosevelt (FDR).

It was the first of its kind between a Saudi monarch and a US president, setting the ground for a solid alliance between the two countries that would outlive both King Abdulaziz and FDR.

It re-surfaced recently with all the talk about a proposed US-Saudi defence agreement, which will only see the light after Israel ends its war on Gaza.

King Abdulaziz had never left the Arabian Peninsula before 1945 nor ridden the high tide. FDR was a sick man with not much longer to live, suffering paralysis since the age of 39, which left him permanently confined to a wheelchair, unable to walk or stand without support.

That didn’t break his resolve, however, and he was elected president four times in a row, setting a precedent in US history – due to the raging war in Europe – that has never been met since then.

His fourth and last term had just started in January 1944, and despite his frail health, Roosevelt insisted on meeting the Saudi king despite the threats of German bombers hovering over the skies of Egypt.

Oil was then a new discovery in Saudi Arabia, still inadequate and unable to fulfil the kingdom’s vast needs.

It had been discovered by US oil companies a few years back, and Saudi Arabia had signed a strategic drilling agreement with Standard Oil of California at the historical Khuzam Palace in Jeddah before extraction began in 1938, only to be suspended by the outbreak of World War II in September 1939.

Getty
King Abdul Aziz Al Saud of Saudi Arabia (1875 - 1953) (centre) and US President Franklin D Roosevelt (1882 - 1945) aboard the USS Quincy in Great Bitter Lake, Egypt February 14, 1945.

The Axis powers had repeatedly tried to disrupt America’s access to Arabian oil, and FDF feared that his British allies would try to seize it, as they had done with the oilfields in Iran, Iraq, and Kuwait.

King Abdulaziz assured him that nothing of the sort would happen so long as he lived, saying that Saudi Arabia was an independent country – the only independent country in the Arab World – and he intended to keep it that way.

Two years before the historic meeting at Suez, the king had sent his two sons to Washington to meet FDR, Emir Faisal and Emir Khaled (who would become kings in their own rights after their father’s death). And when hearing that the US president was an avid stamp collector, he sent him a gift of Saudi stamps, then a rare commodity in the West.

En route to the Suez Canal

The US ship carrying King Abdulaziz to Egypt, USS Murphy, carried food rations that could last 60 days, but the Saudi king refused to eat them. It was inconceivable to eat frozen meat not prepared in the halal manner of Islam, bringing along sheep to be slaughtered and eaten on the spot.

He set up an Arabian tent on the deck and led prayers of his entourage (no less than 47 members), according to Barry McCarthy — one of the Americans onboard who wrote an article about his encounter with Abdulaziz, published in LIFE Magazine on 19 March 1945.

The Saudi king presented him and all his comrades with 15 pounds sterling as a gift and 10 pounds sterling for every American sailor. In return, the ship’s captain presented him with two submachine guns Abdulaziz had admired on board, with a pair of navy binoculars.

A historic meeting

The USS Murphy crossed 1200 km by sea to reach the cruiser carrying FDR. King Abdulaziz moved to the USS Quincy to find FDR waiting on deck in his trademark wheelchair.

The US president broke the ice, saying: “You are luckier than I because you can still walk on your legs.”

King Abdulaziz replied: “No, my friend, you are the more fortunate. Your wheelchair will take you wherever you want to go, and you know you will get there. My legs are less reliable every day and are getting weaker.”

US President Franklin D. Roosevelt ordered that a wheelchair identical to his be presented to King Abdulaziz al-Saud as a gift, with a White House tag on its handle.

Details of this conversation remained unknown until they were revealed in a 47-page book authored by the US representative in Riyadh, William Eddy.

FDR Meets Ibn Saud was published in New York in 1954, and in it, Eddy describes the Saudi king as "one of the great men of the 20th century."

FDR ordered that a wheelchair identical to his be presented to King Abdulaziz as a gift, with a White House tag on its handle.

He was greatly moved to hear that the Saudi King's weak legs were not due to age or illness but rather from the many wars he had fought in his younger years to unite the tribes and lands of Arabia.

In return, King Abdulaziz presented him with silk belts, a diamond-embroidered sword, perfumes for his wife Eleanor, and solid amber from the Red Sea. 

Strategic agreements

The historic meeting lasted for five hours, which included an early working lunch attended by the king's children, a US navy officer, and Charles Bohlen — the American specialist in Soviet affairs who had served as FDR's translator at the Yalta Conference a few days back, where he had met with Joseph Stalin.

British wartime Prime Minister Sir Winston Leonard Spencer Churchill left, U.S. President Franklin Delano Roosevelt, centre, and Soviet leader Joseph Stalin sit on the grounds of the Livadia Palace, Yalta.

Read more: There is hope for Ukraine in how Yalta helped end World War II

During the talks, King Abdulaziz asked for America's friendship, saying that he was confident it would emerge victorious from the war.

Roosevelt agreed to provide the kingdom with US arms and military expertise to build its nascent army. In return, King Abdulaziz promised to secure its safe access to Arabian oil, with a pledge that it would never go neither to the Soviets nor to the Nazis and Fascists.

The issue of Palestine

The most important outcome of the meeting was an agreement over Palestine after FDR raised the issue of 10,000 Jews seeking emigration from Europe.

The US president was firmly committed to Zionism and had relied heavily on the Jewish vote during his last presidential election in 1944. He told King Abdulaziz that he had taken an oath to support them, asking for his opinion.

King Abdulaziz was firm and straightforward: "Give them and their descendants the choicest lands and homes of the Germans who had oppressed them."

FDR gently replied that the Jews had no desire to stay in Germany, fearing another wave of persecution in the future. "They have a sentimental desire to settle in Palestine and, quite understandably, would dream remaining in Germany where they might suffer again."

Amends should be made by the criminal, not by the innocents. What injury have Arabs done to the Jews of Europe? Let the Germans pay.

Saudi King and founder, King Abdulaziz Al Saud

King Abdulaziz said that the Arabs and Jews could not work together, neither in Palestine nor anywhere else in the world, due to bad years of tension, blood, and mutual mistrust.

"The Germans should be made to give up territory for this purpose", he said, adding: "They were the aggressors and had committed the crimes and oppression against the Jews."

King Abdulaziz went on to emphasise: "Make the enemy pay. That is how we Arabs wage war. Amends should be made by the criminal, not by the innocents. What injury have Arabs done to the Jews of Europe? Let the Germans pay!"

After an intense five hours of marathon talks, FDR finally agreed that "no decision would be taken with respect to the basic situation in Palestine without full consultation with both Arabs and Jews."

For the Saudi monarch, no assurance could have been better. Real men like him, he believed, were held by their word of honour, not by any written agreements on paper that could be scrapped at any time.

FDR would soon put his verbal pledge in writing on 5 April 1945, when two weeks before his death, he wrote to King Abdulaziz.

"It gives me pleasure to renew to Your Majesty the assurances which you have previously received…with regard to the question of Palestine and to inform you that the policy of this government in this respect is unchanged," he said.

Had Roosevelt lived longer, then he would have undoubtedly honoured his word, but his death on 12 April 1945 put an end to his commitment to the Saudi king, as his successor, Harry Truman, came to the Oval Office and voted in favour of the partition of Palestine in 1947.

He didn't consult with King Abdulaziz and took the decision to recognise the state of Israel unilaterally, in complete disregard of Arab and Islamic public opinion.

It was the Americans then who breached the King Abdulaziz-FDR agreement, not the Saudis nor FDR himself.

On its part, Saudi Arabia remained committed to its pledge, helping combat Nazism first, then communism, before positioning itself as a bulwark in the international war against fundamentalism, terrorism, and Islamic radicalisation.

* This article was published on 17 February 2024 on the 79th anniversary of the King Abdulaziz-FDR summit. We are re-posting it today as it is related to the cover story.

font change

Related Articles