Gandhi: A supporter of Palestine and fierce critic of Zionism

Gandhi's opposition to British rule informed his politics and Indian Muslims were key players in the anti-colonial movement

The iconic Indian nationalist leader famously said: 'Palestine belongs to the Arabs in the same sense as England belongs to the English and France to the French.'
Majalla
The iconic Indian nationalist leader famously said: 'Palestine belongs to the Arabs in the same sense as England belongs to the English and France to the French.'

Gandhi: A supporter of Palestine and fierce critic of Zionism

At 5:17 pm on 30 January 1948, Mahatma Gandhi was shot three times on his way to a prayer meeting. He died instantly, aged 78.

The assassin, Nathuram Godse, was a Hindu nationalist who felt that Gandhi had given Muslims way too many concessions during the partition of India. He didn’t even try to escape and was arrested, put on trial, and hanged in November 1949.

Throughout his illustrious career, Gandhi had strongly advocated religious pluralism. After India got its independence in August 1947, the country was partitioned into two dominions: a Hindu-majority India and a Muslim-majority Pakistan.

Hindus, Muslims, and Sikhs were uprooted from their homes, and religious violence erupted, prompting the Mahatma to stage a series of hunger strikes aimed at stopping the violence. The last of them was on 12 January 1948, two weeks before his assassination.

Gandhi remains one of the most widely admired and recognisable figures in world history — a titan of the 20th century who inspired non-violent resistance on all four corners of the globe.

At first glance, Gandhi’s career and struggle seem rather unrelated to the Arab world — a region he never visited and to which he had no direct connection. A closer look, however, shows an often-missed connection, which began with Kemal Ataturk’s decision to abolish the Islamic caliphate, previously vested in the Ottoman sultan, in March 1924.

AFP
The body of martyred Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi, known as the Mahatma Gandhi (1869-1948), is carried on 10 February 1948 in New Delhi for the ceremony of cremation.

Gandhi and the Muslim Caliph

Part of the caliph’s duties, some of his functions, and what remained of his funds were transferred entirely to the Turkish parliament.

Ataturk explained: “I must make it clear that those seeking to keep Muslims absorbed in the illusion of the caliphate are the enemies of Muslims.”

Gandhi was appalled. Although not a Muslim, he viewed the caliphate as a symbol of Islamic unity and power. During World War I, it had morphed into a lightweight religious authority. After the guns went silent in 1918, the sultan’s army was crushed, his empire in ruins, and his capital occupied by Western powers.

Once commanding wide respect reaching as far as Muslim Spain and India, the defeated caliph was now a non-entity forced to obey the dictates of Great Britain and France. He had to give up entire parts of Anatolia, relinquish all of Syria, and return Allied prisoners without securing the return of Ottoman soldiers.

On 17 October 1924, the Caliph Abdul Majid II left his throne in Istanbul aboard a British liner headed to Malta, with orders never to return.

A caliphate movement had emerged in India since 1919, which challenged post-World War I attempts at curbing the powers of the caliph before doing away with it altogether. The movement also played a crucial role in forging unity among Hindus and Muslims and in challenging British rule in India.

Gandhi fully supported the Indian caliphate movement, which played a crucial role in forging unity among Hindus and Muslims and in challenging British rule in India.

Gandhi gave the Indian Caliphate Movement his full support, working side-by-side with Muslim leaders like Shaukat Ali and Mohammad Ali Jawhar. He needed Muslim Indians in his fight against the British and supported the Ottoman Empire, which had fought them during the Great War.

By the time the Indian movement emerged and gained momentum, Gandhi was 50. Although it did win him strong support among Muslims, it antagonised hardline Hindus.

In 1924, Gandhi was asked to support a caliphate movement in Syria led by Emir Said al-Jaza'iri — grandson of the Algerian resistance leader Abd al-Qadir al-Jaza'iri.  Emir Said even wrote a letter to Gandhi, seeking support for his nomination for the post, given his lineage to the Prophet Mohammad.

Gandhi replied cordially, backing the restoration of the caliphate in principle but coming short of supporting Emir Said for the job, which was also being contested by King Fuad of Egypt and Sharif Hussein bin Ali of Mecca.

In March 1921, Gandhi spoke to the Bombay Chronicle, saying: "The existence of Islam demands the total abrogation of mandates taken by Britain and France. No influence, direct or indirect, over the Holy Places of Islam will ever be tolerated by Indian Muslims."

"The Muslims claim Palestine…and are bound to retain its custody, as an injunction of the Prophet. But that does not mean that the Jews and the Christians cannot freely go to Palestine or even reside there and own property."

"What non-Muslims cannot do is to acquire sovereign jurisdiction. The Jews cannot receive sovereign rights in a place which has been held for centuries by Muslim powers by rights of religious conquest. The Muslim soldiers did not shed their blood to surrender Palestine out of Muslim control."

Getty
Indian statesmen Mahatma Gandhi (Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi, 1869 - 1948) and Jawaharlal Nehru (1869 - 1964) (left), known as Pandit Nehru, in conversation at the All-India Congress committee meeting at Bombay.

Gandhi and Palestine

Gandhi's opposition to the British in India made him a natural supporter of Palestinian rights and a fierce critic of Zionism.

That came at a relatively late period of his career, however, which, until the early 1930s, had focused on pursuing Indian independence, uplifting the poor, promoting spinning and weaving, and, of course, his trademark: non-violent resistance to British occupation.

Indian Jews were few and un-problematic for Gandhi: fewer than 25,000 in 1930, concentrated mainly in Bombay. They were apolitical and happy in India.

Although the World Zionist Organisation tried talking Gandhi into supporting their programme, he remained adamant, advising Chaim Weizmann to look to "Jerusalem above" as a spiritual place, not an actual home for world Jewry.

During a visit to London to attend a round table conference on India in 1931, Gandhi spoke to The Jewish Chronicle, saying: "Zionism, meaning reoccupation of Palestine, has no appeal to me."

I can understand the longing of a Jew to return to Palestine, and he can do so without the help of bayonets, whether his own or those of Britain. Zionism, meaning the reoccupation of Palestine, has no appeal to me.

Mahatma Gandhi, Indian nationalist

"I can understand the longing of a Jew to return to Palestine, and he can do so if he can without the help of bayonets, whether his own or those of Britain. In that event, he would go to Palestine peacefully and in perfect friendliness with the Arabs."

In his weekly journal Harijan, Gandhi wrote on 26 November 1939: "Palestine belongs to the Arabs in the same sense as England belongs to the English and France to the French."

Eight years later, he and Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru – his loyal disciple – voted against the UN Partition Plan for Palestine when raised at the UN General Assembly in 1947.

Albert Einstein wrote directly to them, saying that the Jews had been "victims of history for centuries." India should think twice, he added, before it stood in the way of Jewish aspirations.

Nehru wrote back, expressing "deepest sympathy for the great suffering of the Jewish people" but added that "national policies are unfortunately essentially selfish."

He and the Mahatma refused to budge on partition.

font change

Related Articles