Syrian refugees in Turkey express worry ahead of crucial vote

Syrian refugees say that up until two years ago Turkey had been very welcoming until racist rhetoric began being used which has led to killings and hate crimes against them

Syrian refugees wait to board a bus as they head to border villages of Edirne province, in Istanbul, Turkey, 28 February 2020.
AFP
Syrian refugees wait to board a bus as they head to border villages of Edirne province, in Istanbul, Turkey, 28 February 2020.

Syrian refugees in Turkey express worry ahead of crucial vote

Istanbul: “We are scared,” a Syrian man in a major Turkish city lamented to Al Majalla.

“I’m having many problems these days.”

“It has become normal to see posters everywhere threatening Syrians. Dehumanising them,” he added, asking that his name not be used so as to speak more openly.

“Three people I normally buy things from – a grocery shop and others – have all said to me something like ‘it’s close to the time you will have to return to Syria, now’,” said the man, who prior to the war in Syria was an English teacher and who speaks English fluently.

He has had a job and a regular salary during the entirety of his stay in the country.

“They’re not joking,” he stressed, and they say it “as if I were taking their money” by being here and working.

His son, now seven years old, was born in Turkey and attends a school at which he speaks only Turkish.

“My wife always used to refuse to even consider moving to another country [farther away from Syria],” he added. “Now she is always asking me to find a way to leave.”

Another younger Syrian man who is also employed and studying at the same time claimed to Al Majalla that “hardly a week goes by without hearing news of a stabbing or killing of Syrians inside Turkey, as a result of the discrimination and hatred that has [been] dangerously escalating and threatens the stability of the country.

Giving voters what they want?

Turkey currently hosts the largest refugee population in the world, though it does not officially recognise them as such.

Since the massive uprisings and violence in Syria that began in 2011, Syrians have comprised by far the lion’s share and are currently thought to number under four million. There are no exact figures available.

Turkey became well known in the wake of mass killings and bombings inflicted by the Syrian government on civilians and armed opposition groups for being more welcoming to those fleeing the conflict, allowing millions to work and create new lives for themselves.

Aid for the northern areas of Syria has long crossed in through Turkey’s border and the country is credited by many Syrians as having saved their lives and the lives of their families.

Following the 14 May first round of voting in which neither of the two top candidates – President Recep Tayyip Erdogan and opposition candidate Kemal Kilicdaroglu – received over 50% of the vote, anti-foreigner sentiment that had already been festering for years amid surging inflation and an increasingly difficult financial situation was further stoked.

Kilicdaroglu notably claimed that there are “10 million” Syrians in Turkey – more than double the number most frequently cited by official bodies – and that his competitor would bring in “10 million more”, warning that “our women” would not be safe if this happens.

Far-right Turkish political leader Umit Ozdag – who has made an anti-refugee stance the rallying call for his Victory Party, claiming there are “13 million” in the country – endorsed Kilicdaroglu after he failed to secure pledges from Erdogan to repatriate migrants and refugees.

In announcing his decision, Ozdag said that Kilicdaroglu had pledged to send back “all refugees” within the first year within the first year of his term if elected.

Sinan Ogan, who is also an ultranationalist and blames many of Turkey’s woes on refugees as well but who came in third in the first round of voting with almost 2.8 million votes, had instead earlier announced his support for Erdogan.

Over six months ago, it was clear that Kilicdaroglu would be betting on an anti-immigrant stance to rack up votes - though many supporting his election sought to instead create an image of him as a “liberal” with democratic principles.

Shelly Kittleson
Photos of the secular founder of the Turkish Republic, Kemal Ataturk, adorn many streets across the country. Istanbul, Turkey. May 19, 2023.

Six months ago it was clear that Kilicdaroglu would be betting on an anti-immigrant stance to rack up votes - though many supporting his election sought to instead create an image of him as a "liberal".

Despite the focus in this latest part of the campaign on pledging to force foreigners – or at least Syrians - to leave the country, a Metropoll survey conducted in early April found that only 2.2% of Turkish voters deemed refugees the country's "most important problem".

A whopping 56% instead said that the dire state of the economy was the issue that needs to be addressed.

Syrians wistful for past welcome

"Turkey was a place of safety and comfort for me," said a younger Syrian man, who was 16 when the conflict still ongoing started across the border.

"I miss the former Turkey that welcomed and defended refugees and gave them the safety they needed.

Shelly Kittleson
Election campaign poster for the top candidate of the opposition pledging to send Syrians back to Syria. May 25, 2023.

Several longstanding Syrian contacts of this Al Majalla journalist including university professors and highly educated Syrians - essentially, those who have long been able to afford to find a way to leave but had previously chosen not to – have in recent months somehow found their way to Europe and said they are requesting asylum there.

The EU border agency reportedly detected 330,000 irregular border crossings into the bloc last year, a 64% rise on the previous year. Most of those entering were Syrians, Afghans and Tunisians.

This young man is also considering trying to find a way to do the same, though this is not really what he wants.

"Almost two years ago, discrimination against refugees in general and Syrians" especially began to be seen more frequently, he said, which "led to the start of killings and assaults targeting Syrians."

"But the Turkish people were not like that," he repeated. "They were a people who welcomed refugees until racist rhetoric appeared and began to affect a small segment of society." 

The Turks welcomed refugees until the racist rhetoric began. This was followed by hate crimes and killings.

Now, however, the main presidential candidates "contradict each other in everything except for [on the issue of] refugees. Both of them make promises to return Syrian refugees to their country and restore diplomatic relations with" Syria, despite President Bashar al-Assad remaining in power.

"Watching these elections is mental torment for me," he added sadly.

Young Turks want religion out of politics

Some younger Turks from religious families but who now say religion plays little to no real role in their lives say they are voting simply to get Erdogan out.

They don't actually care about what pledges the opposition makes, one told Al Majalla in the week prior to the 28 May runoff.

One man in his 30s who had attended an Imam Hatip religious school – as did Erdogan - said he had initially been planning to vote for ultranationalist Ogan in the first round but ended up voting for Kilicdaroglu since he thought this would give him a greater chance at winning.

Shelly Kittleson
Election posters for President Recep Tayyip Erdogan near an Imam Hatip school. Istanbul, Turkey. May 24, 2023.

He added that whenever the subject of voting for anyone other than Erdogan comes up, however, his parents say, "Don't you remember 28 February?"

"They don't want that to happen again," he said.

The reference is to what Daily Sabah once called the 1997 "post-modern coup" and a "scar on the psyche of the Turkish nation".

The "February 28 Memorandum" issued by the Turkish military at that time was a series of resolutions against what it saw as "rising Islamist ideology".

It included the shutting down of Imam Hatip schools and the banning of "women wearing headscarves from entering any public buildings, including schools and universities."

This ban caused millions of young women to either give up their education or suffer while trying to receive a proper one.

Female teachers were also dismissed from their jobs if they refused to remove their headscarves and the abhorred practice of 'persuasion rooms' was launched in universities, where headscarf-wearing students would be 'persuaded' to remove their headscarves amid threats of expulsion from the school.

Women wearing headscarves were also not permitted to work," according to an article by Daily Sabah published on the 24th anniversary.

Five years later, in 2002, Erdogan was elected for the first time.

The Turkish man - who is in his 30s, has a university degree and has travelled extensively abroad - said that he frequently argues with many fellow former Imam Hatip students on the subject of the current president and what is best for the future of the country.

On the issue of refugees, he said "women, kids and older people" should be welcomed but young men should not be allowed in, claiming "they are not refugees, they [come here to] enjoy life" and that they distort "the demography of the country".

Religious areas of Istanbul

Having received almost 50% of the vote in the first round and seen as likely to win the second round, Erdogan retains a great deal of popularity in many areas of this cosmopolitan, Europe-leaning city.

Even in districts known for a high concentration of cafes popular with affluent, liberal Westerners there are large banners across some of the streets with Erdogan's photo and local youth sections proudly proclaiming their support for him.

Shelly Kittleson
Election campaign poster for Turkish president Recep Tayyip Erdogan. Istanbul,Turkey, May 25, 2023.

Major streets nearby are plastered with posters of Kilicdaroglu's bespectacled visage.

But wandering through a popular street market in a less affluent area a few days prior to the runoff, only photos of Erdogan were lovingly propped up on tables, hung across streets or on buildings. A few were pasted onto walls and wooden surfaces.

And while many Syrians believe that whoever wins will be under immense pressure to "force refugees out", some think a win by Erdogan might result in less discriminatory rhetoric and government decisions based more on Islamic principles – and thus, possibly, the only hope they have of not having to uproot their lives once again in the immediate future.

font change

Related Articles