Shenzhen: a peace to end all peace?

Time will tell whether the meeting between the world's three great powers will help end wars or simply become a blueprint for managing them

Shenzhen: a peace to end all peace?

The Shenzhen summit, which brought together the presidents of the United States, China and Russia, has drawn comparisons to the 1945 Yalta Conference, when American, Soviet and British leaders met to discuss the shape of the post-war world.

What makes this summit different is that Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin met before the guns had fallen silent, amid a race for influence, nuclear weapons and artificial intelligence. While the meeting produced a "Declaration Towards Peace", there was no agreement on ending the wars in Iran and Ukraine.

Of the declaration's four provisions, two concern Middle Eastern security, although neither mentions the region by name: stable energy flows and nuclear non-proliferation. The first raises the question of maritime security in the Strait of Hormuz and Bab al-Mandab Strait; the second concerns the future of Iran's nuclear programme. Both issues lie at the heart of the US-Israeli war with Tehran.

On energy, the declaration called for increased production and supplies of petroleum products and stressed the importance of stable energy flows. The language has an economic tinge, yet it carries crucial security implications. Iran can threaten shipping through the Strait of Hormuz, while its Houthi proxies can endanger vessels in Bab al-Mandab and the Red Sea. Neither waterway needs to be completely closed to disrupt supplies. Threats to tankers, rising insurance costs and the diversion of shipping routes are enough to threaten economies around the world.

The three powers share an interest in stable energy supplies, although their calculations differ. China, the world's largest importer of crude oil, depends heavily on foreign supplies, including oil from the Gulf. The US, despite its vast domestic production, remains vulnerable to rising global prices. Trump knows this only too well after his party's midterm election defeat.

The three great powers spoke of peace but sought to define the limits of accountability

For its part, Russia is a major energy exporter that may benefit from higher prices, although it too is affected by market disruption. In the end, the three "friends" agreed on the importance of keeping energy flowing, yet reached no agreement to end the war threatening those supplies. 

Nuclear issue

On the nuclear question, the leaders affirmed that a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought, pledging dialogue to reduce risks and curb proliferation. They all oppose Tehran acquiring a nuclear weapon, but disagree over how to prevent it. The US favours war, while Russia and China favour diplomacy. In the end, the "Peace Declaration" left the thorny issues of Iranian uranium enrichment, enriched nuclear material, inspection mechanisms and safeguards open.

For Middle Eastern countries, the nuclear issue is a key concern, but far from the only one. Iranian missiles and drones also pose a serious threat—something Gulf states became acutely aware of this year, after being on the receiving end of such attacks. The declaration offered neither a vision for regional security nor guarantees for countries exposed to the consequences of war.

There was also no agreement to end the war in Ukraine, no rules set regarding AI competition and no commitment to reduce nuclear arsenals. The "Peace Declaration" did, however, warn the International Criminal Court against abusing its jurisdiction. The three great powers spoke of peace but sought to define the limits of accountability.

Although talks among the three great powers may lessen the danger of direct confrontation between them, they offer no guarantee of peace for others

More than a century ago, the victors of World War I believed they were laying the foundations of a lasting peace. Yet the arrangements they devised paved the path to further wars. In his book, A Peace to End All Peace, David Fromkin explained how decisions taken by the great powers after the collapse of the Ottoman Empire shaped the modern Middle East and planted seeds of future conflicts.

No Yalta 2.0

But Shenzhen is no Yalta 2.0. Today's wars are still active; the three powers are not allies, nor have they agreed on carving up the world into spheres of influence. influence.  announced no division of spheres of influence. However, the comparison raises an important question: can peace be proclaimed from above without addressing the causes of conflict and the interests of the concerned societies?

Although talks among the three great powers may lessen the danger of direct confrontation between them, they offer no guarantee of peace for others. Time will tell whether the "Declaration Towards Peace" will help end wars or simply become a blueprint for managing them. The rest of the world will hope the declaration does not become another Peace to End All Peace.

font change