Amid Gaza's decimation, words have lost all meaning

When massacres are met with such indifference, silence is the only thing that seems fitting

Amid Gaza's decimation, words have lost all meaning

A Palestinian man carries his brother’s severed arm, the only part of him that remains. He carries it in a daze through a land of ruin as a group of journalists place the remains of a colleague into plastic bags. “This is all that’s left,” they say. In one of Gaza's few barely functioning hospitals, a doctor is forced to amputate the limbs of nine children from a single Israeli air strike. Tell me when this gets too much. Tell me when you’ve read enough.

Emotions can rarely be conveyed amid such visible, audible, and raw suffering. They certainly cannot be captured by words. ‘Sympathy,’ ‘sorrow,’ ‘pain': these words do not even scratch the surface of how we feel. And though many still hesitate to use it, even the word ‘genocide’ has lost its weight, as have all attempts to explain the unfolding events in political or moral terms.

We are all witnesses

Recognising the truth of today’s events—understanding what is happening, who the victims are, and who (or what) made them victims—will fall to future generations. This may be the heaviest burden that they inherit. Living through this terrifying moment, we are all witnesses, whether we like it or not. No one can say they didn't know.

Words like 'sympathy,' 'sorrow,' or 'pain' do not even scratch the surface of how we feel. Amid Gaza's decimation, words have lost all meaning.

Glued to our screens, watching the horror unfold, it can feel like an act of self-preservation to put the phone down and think of something else, to spare our fragile hearts the weight of what we see and read. But those being bombed cannot switch off.

On TV, radio, and social media platforms, the same tired discussions and debates are being had—the same plotline with the same old talking heads. Occasionally, someone is able to cut through the propaganda to speak the truth, but those who spout their rehearsed talking points continue to turn a blind eye to it.

Reading the room

The predictable policy statements of governments, international organisations, and even the war's protagonists have lost their significance. They can say what they want. They can judge, criticise, accuse, exonerate, or hold responsible whoever they want. Worst nightmares are now a waking reality. What they say matters, not a jot. Their words are but babble and murmur amidst the tombstones.

Broadcasters sit safely in distant studios, filling the airwaves with analysis and predictions over the next air strike, wondering where it will hit, how large it will be, what form it will take, what impact it will have, and who it will kill. It is flotsam. As the cameras roll, streets crash and crumble live on air; existence is reduced to rubble in the blink of an eye as commentators search for the right words. They quickly find there are none.

What do words even matter at this point?  When blood flows this freely, when destruction is this vast, and when bodies and landscapes are torn apart so gruesomely, words no longer have meaning. 

When blood flows this freely and when bodies are torn apart so gruesomely, words no longer have meaning. 

The dead certainly don't care about what pundits will say of their murder. Families wiped off the civil registry do not seek clarification over who killed them. They know who did this. Everyone does.

The executioner has killed so many that it seems futile at this point to name him. His capacity to kill seems infinite. He is indifferent if Palestinians live or die. Indeed, this scale of brutality is only possible because of this indifference.

When massacres are met with such indifference, words lose their meaning, and silence is the only thing that seems fitting. In this terrifying world, no words, analysis, context, or script can ever offer a modicum of justice or comfort. So, put your tired debates and discussions away. 

font change