Will Israel's war on Gaza impact the outcome of the upcoming UK elections?

Labour MPs have warned Starmer that the party faces an "existential threat" in seats with a large number of Muslim voters as councillors continue to quit and local parties pass motions in favour of a ceasefire.

Labour Party leader Starmer has taken a lot of heat for his refusal to call for a ceasefire in Israel's war on Gaza. Al Majalla explains how this issue could impact Britain's upcoming elections.
AlMajalla/Agencies
Labour Party leader Starmer has taken a lot of heat for his refusal to call for a ceasefire in Israel's war on Gaza. Al Majalla explains how this issue could impact Britain's upcoming elections.

Will Israel's war on Gaza impact the outcome of the upcoming UK elections?

With the next British general election rapidly approaching, the global crisis over the war in Gaza could provide the beleaguered Conservative Party a much-needed boost to its electoral fortunes.

After Hamas launched its devastating attack against Israel on 7 October, a deep political divide arose between the Conservative government of Prime Minister Rishi Sunak, who immediately pledged his administration to support Israel’s military response to the attack, and the opposition Labour party, under the leadership of Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer, who is more conflicted about how to deal with the issue.

While Sir Keir initially followed Sunak’s lead by giving his backing to Israel’s right to self-defence, other leading members of the Labour Party have proved less supportive, with many prominent Labour politicians accusing Israel of collective punishment and calling for a ceasefire.

The deep tensions in the Labour Party broke into the open after Starmer gave an interview to LBC radio’s interviewer Nick Ferrari.

The broadcaster asked the Labour leader if “a siege — cutting off power, cutting off water” to Gaza was a proportionate response to the massacre by Hamas on 7 October. Civilians in Gaza have been dying in their thousands. Necessities – food, water, fuel, medicines – are in critically short supply.

“Yes,” Starmer said, Israel did have the right to defend itself. Having banished the spectre of anti-Semitism under former leader Jeremy Corbyn from his party, he wasn’t about to offer a hostage to fortune before a general election.

Starmer suspended Corbyn from the Labour Party after a damning official report into anti-Semitism in the Labour party in October 2020.

The equalities watchdog found that the party was guilty of “unlawful acts of harassment and discrimination” involving anti-Semitism during Mr Corbyn’s leadership. Furthermore, in 2009, Mr Corbyn had called Hamas and Hezbollah “friends” during a meeting in parliament.

But Starmer’s response in the LBC interview badly misjudged the depth of feeling in the party at the plight of ordinary Gazans — especially among British Muslims.

Labour’s metro-mayors Sadiq Khan and Andy Burnham, both running cities – London and Manchester respectively – with large Muslim populations, broke ranks and called for a ceasefire.

So did the leader of the Scottish Labour Party, Anas Sarwar, who, like his SNP rival, the Scottish First Minister Humza Yousaf, has family in Gaza.

Labour's metro-mayors Sadiq Khan and Andy Burnham, both running cities – London and Manchester respectively – with large Muslim populations, broke ranks with Keir Starmer and called for a ceasefire.

Although Starmer has claimed his comments have been misinterpreted, Labour has been divided ever since, and more than 20 Labour councillors have resigned, causing the party to lose control of the council. 

Yet, despite days of criticism from inside his party and calls for him to ask for a formal ceasefire, Starmer has stuck to his position, insisting that a full ceasefire would only strengthen Hamas.

In a speech at Chatham House in London on Tuesday this week, he repeated a call for a humanitarian pause to allow people out of the enclave and let aid in, in line with the position of both the US and UK governments.

"It is the only credible approach which has a chance of what we all want to see in Gaza," he said. He added that he understood why people wanted a ceasefire in response to "horrifying" scenes of civilian suffering.

Starmer argued a permanent ceasefire at this stage would leave Hamas with the infrastructure and capability to carry out the sort of attack seen on 7 October, risking more misery and suffering for Israelis and Palestinians.

"Hamas would be emboldened and would start preparing for future violence immediately," he said. "It is, of course, also holding 200 hostages; you cannot freeze that situation without denying a sovereign state its self-defence."

While Sunak has so far managed to maintain a united front on the Gaza issue, Starmer is now battling to maintain Labour discipline with members of his frontbench in open revolt about his stance on Israel's war on Gaza

Labour Party divisions

The deepening row within the Labour Party over how to respond to the Gaza crisis has undoubtedly provided a boost to the ruling Conservatives, which, prior to the Hamas attack, was trailing badly in the opinion polls and looked set to suffer heavy losses at the next general British election, which is due to take place next year.

And while it is still too early to judge whether the differing approaches of Britain's leading parties will have an impact on the eventual election outcome, it is clear that Sunak's more robust support for Israel has enhanced his leadership credentials, with only a few backbench Conservative MPs voicing concerns on the ceasefire issue.

By contrast, significant numbers of front bench Labour MPs have criticised Starmer's approach and tested the party's collective responsibility by calling for a full ceasefire and the Labour leader was harangued by a knot of leftwing protesters as he arrived for the speech at Chatham House in London.

While Sunak has so far managed to maintain a united front on the Gaza issue, Starmer is now battling to maintain Labour discipline with members of his frontbench in open revolt about his stance on Israel's war on Gaza.

Sixteen Labour frontbenchers are opposed to Starmer's position and Labour MPs have told The Independent newspaper that at least 100 of Sir Keir's MPs – half his parliamentary party – want him to shift stance to avoid losing further support.

They warned the Labour leader that the party faces an "existential threat" in seats with a large number of Muslim voters as councillors continue to quit and local parties pass motions in favour of a ceasefire.

Labour MPs have warned Starmer that the party faces an "existential threat" in seats with a large number of Muslim voters as councillors continue to quit and local parties pass motions in favour of a ceasefire.

This comes as a YouGov survey found that 42% of 2019 Labour voters think Starmer has mishandled his response to the conflict, while only 26% think he has responded well.

Starmer has also seen a significant drop in his personal ratings among the wider British public, with a survey by DeltaPoll showing Starmer's net approval has dropped by 12%, from +7 to -5. 

There is still some time before Britain goes to the polls, but it is not inconceivable that the terrible events taking place in Gaza could still have a direct impact on the outcome of Britain's next general election.

font change

Related Articles