Jeddah summit on Ukraine crisis showcases fresh perspectives on global security

The global south can offer unique perspectives on how to preserve global security in an evolving multipolar world

Delegates from more than 40 countries including China, India, and the US, pose for a family picture as they attend talks in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, August 6, 2023, to make headway towards a peaceful end to Russia's war in Ukraine.
Reuters
Delegates from more than 40 countries including China, India, and the US, pose for a family picture as they attend talks in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, August 6, 2023, to make headway towards a peaceful end to Russia's war in Ukraine.

Jeddah summit on Ukraine crisis showcases fresh perspectives on global security

This past weekend saw Saudi Arabia playing a central role in gathering senior officials and representatives from over 40 countries in the port city of Jeddah to discuss Ukraine’s Peace Plan. This meeting is the second of its kind following the last gathering in Copenhagen in June.

While Russia and Ukraine refuse to negotiate directly, such gatherings are helpful to work toward achieving progress toward ending the conflict.

While the Copenhagen summit did not attract high-level officials and had no concrete outcome, the Jeddah summit produced tangible steps to resolve the conflict by setting up working groups at the national security adviser level.

China — represented by Li Hui, the special representative of the Chinese Government on Eurasian Affairs — responded positively and welcomed the idea of having a third meeting on the same level as the Jeddah summit. This is another step forward for China to play a constructive role in the search for common ground on the conflict since Li’s trip to Ukraine, Russia, and several European countries in May.

Meanwhile, as Saudi Arabia exercises its growing strategic autonomy, it is eager to demonstrate how decentralised power is redefining the global security landscape which is demonstrated by the Middle East's ability to attract well-matched state actors to its capitals.

Reuters
Delegates from more than 40 countries including China, India, and the US, pose for a family picture as they attend talks in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, August 6, 2023, to make headway towards a peaceful end to Russia's war in Ukraine.

Saudi Arabia, in particular, is able to leverage its national strength to chart a path to gradually become a major power of global influence by adopting a foreign and security policy approach based on its own national interests. The level of agility in Saudi Arabia’s external policy and actions demonstrates its effectiveness on the global stage.

Saudi Arabia is able to leverage its strength to chart a path to gradually become a major power of global influence by adopting a foreign policy approach based on its own national interests.

Advancing national interests in a multipolar world

Since the US shifted its focus from counter-terrorism to major power competition — primarily with China and Russia — the Kingdom has been able to reap strategic and practical benefits by adjusting its oil production and collaborating with Russia on oil imports to compete with the US.

In the meantime, while maintaining its policy of neutrality, the Kingdom provided $400mn in aid to Ukraine. Saudi Arabia has leveraged its oil supremacy before, when it collaborated with Russia to reduce oil production leading to the rise of oil prices globally.

Despite such practices, the Kingdom continues to balance its longstanding security relationship with the US and trade relationship with China, reaping benefits from both sides. This form of strategic diplomacy helps Riyadh to consolidate its role in global governance while protecting its national interest.

Saudi Arabia is able to balance its longstanding security relationship with the US and trade relationship with China, reaping benefits from both sides.

It should be noted, however, that effective global governance in today's world still very much depends on effective governance in global security as the Russia-Ukraine conflict alone is challenging and has the potential to reshape the global order.

While many speculated the Jeddah meeting could have been an attempt by some to further isolate Russia and win support from more global south countries who have refrained from taking a clear side, Riyadh was well-placed to host a group of global south countries, particularly China who did not attend the Copenhagen meeting.

The significance of the deepened participation of global south countries in the global security and conflict resolution arena lies in their different perceptions of global security.

China well placed to play leading role

On its part, China — a major power from the global south — believes that it can play a leading role in the regional and global security landscape.

Reuters
Visitors stand in front of a giant screen displaying Chinese President Xi Jinping next to a flag of the Communist Party of China, at the Military Museum of the Chinese People's Revolution in Beijing, China October 8, 2022.

First, China believes security is a prerequisite for development. In the Middle East region, security has been China's top policy concern before it made economic and trade relations with the region a priority. This approach also applies to other regions, including Eurasia.

China believes that sovereign states should be solely responsible for their security and should ensure that security risks do not turn into strategic risks. As such, respecting the sovereignty of all states should be a precursor to conflict resolution.

Second, China believes security should be internalised from the bottom up. A state should always prioritise the security and safety of its own citizens. Maintaining public security paves the way for social security and ultimately state security that will be fully capable of protecting its national security.

Third, China believes that multilateralism remains the most effective and irreplaceable mechanism for world peace. Security needs to be managed and governed under a multilateral framework — namely the UN. Regional and international security risks and problems should be addressed through consultation.

China believes that multilateralism remains the most effective mechanism for world peace and that security needs to be managed under a multilateral framework — namely the UN.

The Jeddah meeting marks the start of the international community's new attempt at providing a multilateral platform where senior officials — at the national security advisor level or with the capacity to address national and international security issues with their heads of state — can build consensus on what security means today and tomorrow; and put forward united steps to achieve global security and stability.

Today we live in a world where the global south is more confident and can provide a different and useful perspective on how to achieve global security. Let's hear these countries out.

font change

Related Articles