Can James Bond survive the Sensitivity Reader?

Long before being ‘woke’ entered the lexicon, there were doubts about 007’s questionable attitudes and behaviour

While Daniel Craig was able to portray a more sensitive James Bond, the 007 of the Bond novels was a misogynist and racist
Nicola Ferrarese
While Daniel Craig was able to portray a more sensitive James Bond, the 007 of the Bond novels was a misogynist and racist

Can James Bond survive the Sensitivity Reader?

We tend to forget that one of cinema’s abiding action men took his name from a birdwatcher. Yet Ian Fleming, himself an avid enthusiast of all things avian, took the name from the American writer of a field guide called Birds of the West Indies.

He came across the book while living in Jamaica and told the author’s wife that “this brief, unromantic, Anglo-Saxon and yet very masculine name was just what I needed, and so a second James Bond was born.”

In a 1962 interview for the New Yorker, Fleming added: “When I wrote the first one in 1953, I wanted Bond to be an extremely dull, uninteresting man to whom things happened... when I was casting around for a name for my protagonist I thought by God, [James Bond] is the dullest name I ever heard.”

Dull?

It’s incredible to think that, had it not been for an obscure ornithologist, James Bond could have been your average Joe. Joe Bloggs, even. Instead, he is the subject of one of the most successful film franchises in the world, a household name and an exemplar of Britannic cool.

At least, in theory. There are, of course, his somewhat unreconstructed attitudes to consider, but (according to Charlie Higson, author of the Young Bond books) Daniel Craig has “given us woke 007, who’s tender, cries and gets into the shower in his tuxedo to comfort a woman.”

Craig was keen to ensure the inclusion of strong women in the Bond franchise. He even revealed that he chose to wear his now famous blue swimming trunks in 2006’s Casino Royale as an antidote to bikini-clad ‘Bond Girls.’

So much for the films. What about the novels themselves?

Bond the misogynist

The Bond that Ian Fleming gave to the world is wont to fantasise about rape. He views women as necessary distractions, there to be enjoyed then cast aside. When not doing that, he’s, at best, condescending, at worst downright insulting towards people of different ethnicity. The villains he meets are stereotypical outcasts: mad, disabled, disfigured even. They are the very embodiments of evil and frequently have Eastern European origins.

Of course, they never prevail, but after confronting and defeating so many villains over the years, James Bond may finally have met his match in the form of an adversary from the future: Sensitivity Reader.

After confronting and defeating so many villains over the years, James Bond may finally have met his match in the form of an adversary from the future: Sensitivity Reader.  

One could say he had it coming. There's a limit to how many high-profile homicides even a very suave serial killer can expect to get away with. Possessing a licence to do this from Her (or His) Majesty sounds like the kind of flimsy excuse calculated to annoy your average villainous foreigner even more.

Read more: The kid gloves are off

But not, apparently, his latest foe. Sensitivity Reader is prepared to overlook the occasional homicide. What really aggravates Sensitivity Reader is the casual misogyny and equally casual racism.

It's the attitudes, rather than the conduct, of this unreconstructed manifestation of patriarchy that has Sensitivity Reader spitting feathers. There's nothing in the world 'they' hate more than heteronormativity.

We tend to think of this age we're living through as uniquely sensitive, but maybe that is the complacent view of every age. Back when the word 'snowflake' still meant a frozen raindrop, Dr Johnson couldn't handle the ending of King Lear.

Criticism dates back to the 1950s

More surprising still is the revelation that soon after Bond's inception back in 1958 — a time when woke was still the grammatically correct 'awoken' — Fleming's hero was already being criticised for his bad behaviour.

Getty Images
Daniel Craig attends a special event hosted by Omega to celebrate 60 years of James Bond on November 23, 2022 in London, England.

In the New Statesman, Paul Johnson wrote an article called 'Sex, Snobbery and Sadism' where he declared Dr No "without doubt, the nastiest book I have ever read… a third of the way through, I had to suppress a strong impulse to throw the thing away." 

He recognised in Bond "a social phenomenon of some importance,"but this he saw as a negative element, as the phenomenon concerned "three basic ingredients, all unhealthy, all thoroughly English: the sadism of a schoolboy bully, the mechanical, two-dimensional sex-longings of a frustrated adolescent, and the crude, snob-cravings of a suburban adult."

[Dr No contains] three basic ingredients, all unhealthy, all thoroughly English: the sadism of a schoolboy bully, the mechanical, two-dimensional sex-longings of a frustrated adolescent, and the crude, snob-cravings of a suburban adult.

Paul Johnson

Honestly, who knew people were such snowflakes in the Fifties?

Higson, who has been given the task of writing a new Bond story for King Charles coronation in May, asked in the Radio Times if the original Bond could "survive in our modern world, or would cancel culture succeed where Spectre has failed so often and finish him off for good."

It's arguable that this has already happened on celluloid. In 'No Time to Die', when Bond retires to Jamaica, he's effectively killed off. Going to meet his maker, or his namesake, he seems poised to take up birdwatching.

Jamaican Bond

In his absence, and continuing the Jamaican connection, his job title is taken by Lashana Lynch, a second-generation Jamaican Londoner. It's a tantalising moment, demonstrating just how far from his original appearance and attitudes 007 could get, but it turns out that for this particular ornithologist, there's nowhere to hide. He is soon back to the old routine of dodging bullets, though he fails (spoiler alert!) to dodge a missile.

Nomi (Lashana Lynch) is ready for action in Cuba in the latest James Bond adventure, "No Time to Die."

Who knows if Bond will have any more luck surviving the decisive intervention of The Reader?

For the new Bond to pass muster, he doesn't just have to rein in the pejorative references and the machismo attitude. He has to learn to act like a normal, well-adjusted citizen of the 21st century. Yes, he gets to retain the firearms, but in all other respects he has to mend his ways.

For the new Bond to pass muster, he doesn't just have to rein in the pejorative references and the machismo attitude. He has to learn to act like a normal, well-adjusted citizen of the 21st century. Yes, he gets to retain the firearms, but in all other respects he has to mend his ways.

From now on, the demeanour will not be arrogant and entitled. Lest anyone be shaken, even stirred, his new incarnation is inoffensive to a fault. It's a different iteration altogether: trigger happy, but not triggering.

On the other hand, it may be a return to his creator's original intentions. The name's Bloggs. Joe Bloggs.    

Charlie Higson's new Bond novel will be entitled 'On His Majesty's Secret Service'.

font change

Related Articles