100 days into office, Sunak fails to live up to promises

Apart from a series of controversies under his tenure, Sunak has had to contend with waves of industrial unrest not seen since the 1970s

100 days into office, Sunak fails to live up to promises

When Rishi Sunak became British prime minister last year, he entered Downing Street promising to restore good government after a period of extraordinary turbulence.

But, as he marked his 100 days in office last week, his period in power has been anything but calm. It’s an important milestone for a leader when judgments about his performance start to form.

Andy Edwards
100 days into his job as premier, Sunak's ruling term has been anything but calm.

Tory MPs gave him the job in reaction to the chaos generated by his predecessors, Liz Truss and Boris Johnson.

He said he would restore confidence in the government’s fiscal competence after Liz Truss’s short-lived time in office saw the pound tumbling while government borrowing costs soared and, he said, he would rebuild trust in the government’s ethical integrity after the questionable moral antics of the Johnson premiership.

“This government will have integrity, professionalism and accountability at every level,” Sunak declared in his first speech outside Number 10.

“Trust is earned and I will earn yours.”

Intense scrutiny

Those comments are now facing intense scrutiny after Sunak was forced to sack Nadhim Zahawi — a key ally who served as chairman of the ruling Conservative Party, after an investigation into his tax affairs found that he had breached the ministerial code.

AFP
In this file photo taken on July 5, 2022 Britain's Education Secretary Nadhim Zahawi arrives to attend a cabinet meeting in Downing Street in London.

Sunak had little choice other than to sack Zahawi following publication of the report written by Sir Laurie Magnus, Sunak’s ethics advisor, which found that Zahawi, who was born in Baghdad to Kurdish parents, had committed seven breaches of the ministerial code.

But for a prime minister who has built his reputation on bringing a degree of probity to British public life, his failure to act sooner has attracted fierce criticism, with opposition Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer questioning whether Sunak has the necessary qualities to run the country.

This is because rumours have been swirling around Westminster for several weeks that Zahawi had been forced to pay a tax fine despite serving a brief sting as Chancellor of the Exchequer, placing him in charge of Britain’s finances.

Zahawi, finally admitted that he was obliged to pay a penalty, believed to be in excess of £1m, as part of a £5m settlement with HMRC for unpaid tax for what he called a “careless error”. The head of the HMRC has since commented that there are no penalties for “innocent errors”.

As a consequence, all the progress Sunak and his team have made to restoring some semblance of stability to Britain’s finances following the chaos surrounding last year’s short-lived Truss administration has now been undone.

As a consequence (of the Zahawi affair), all the progress Sunak and his team have made to restoring some semblance of stability to Britain's finances following the chaos surrounding last year's short-lived Truss administration has now been undone.

Until the Zahawi affair erupted, Sunak could claim he had succeeded to the extent that financial markets think Britain is now under more reliable management, even though this has been achieved by raising taxes to their highest level since the 1950s. 

At the same time Sunak has had to contend with waves of industrial unrest not seen since the 1970s, with the biggest wave of strike action hitting public services — from rail workers to nurses — while the NHS was caught up in another winter crisis.

It is however, his promise to instil "integrity, professionalism and accountability" in government that has been most severely compromised. 

Additional pressure 

Apart from the difficulty he has faced over Zahawi, Sunak is also under pressure over assistance the Conservative-appointed chairman of the BBC, Richard Sharp, gave former Prime Minister Boris Johnson over his finances. 

The public appointments commission is investigating Sharp over claims he was put forward for the BBC role by Johnson only weeks after Mr Sharp facilitated discussions about securing an undisclosed £800,000 loan for the then prime minister with a Canadian multimillionaire as the guarantor.

Meanwhile  Deputy Prime Minister Dominic Raab is the subject of an investigation into complaints that he mistreated officials in several departments.

Nor are these the only poor judgments Mr Sunak has made about personnel. He gave a seat in cabinet to Sir Gavin Williamson even though he had been removed from the cabinet twice before – only for Sir Gavin to resign, pursued by complaints of bullying and accusations from a former deputy he had employed, of "unethical and immoral" working methods when he was Chief Whip. 

AFP
Britain's Prime Minister Rishi Sunak speaking during the weekly session of Prime Minister's Questions (PMQs) at the House of Commons, in London, on February 1, 2023.

Sunak also brought back Suella Braverman as Home Secretary just six days after she had been forced to quit for security breaches that violated the ministerial code. 

He restored Raab to the position of Deputy Prime Minister after the fall of Truss, which could prove to be an unwise choice if the inquiry into Mr Raab doesn't clear him of misconduct towards civil servants.

On Ukraine, despite fears in some quarters that Sunak might be less forthcoming in his support for the government in Kyiv, he has taken a lead, becoming the first Nato leader to commit to sending modern western battle tanks. 

On Ukraine, despite fears in some quarters that Sunak might be less forthcoming in his support for the government in Kyiv, he has taken a lead, becoming the first Nato leader to commit to sending modern western battle tanks. 

In Europe, the sense he is prepared to take a less confrontational approach over Brexit has raised hopes a resolution can finally be found in the long-running dispute with Brussels over the implementation of the Northern Ireland Protocol.

But a clear sign that Sunak's premiership is already in trouble is evident from the fact that the political conservative magazine The Spectator, the bible of the right wing, does not appear to be convinced he is the right man for the job. 

Earlier this month an article opined: "The suspicion is growing that the third prime minister in a year is as unequal to the grave crises confronting him as his dethroned predecessors. A smooth air of competence is not enough when the country is crying out for tough leadership and at least the appearance of action." 

The article continued: "In the crisis facing us rather more than Rishi Sunak's watchwords of 'integrity, professionalism and accountability' are needed – and they are needed now."
 

font change