Elon Musk: America's increasingly unpopular DOGE czar

The South African billionaire tasked with cutting US government spending is Trump's cheerleader for now, but as he accumulates critics both inside and outside the White House, it seems he may not last

Nash Weerasekera

Elon Musk: America's increasingly unpopular DOGE czar

For someone once known for his highly critical views on Donald Trump’s political credentials, the transformation of billionaire entrepreneur Elon Musk into the US president’s most high-profile cheerleader represents one of the more remarkable turnarounds in recent American history.

It was not that long ago that South African-born Musk, whose business interests ranged from his Tesla electric vehicle empire to space exploration, gave the distinct impression that he had little time for Trump.

Prior to Trump’s victory in the 2016 presidential election contest, the 53-year-old Musk openly criticised his candidacy, claiming he was “not the right guy” and that he did not have the “character that reflects well” on the US presidency.

Since then, Musk’s political outlook has shifted markedly to the right—especially since his 2022 takeover of Twitter, which he subsequently rebranded X and used to promote a more right-of-centre agenda.

The result is that Musk now finds himself at the heart of the new Trump administration, enjoying the status of a “special government employee”—a designation used by presidents over the years to allow outside experts to lend their knowledge to the government without having to give up their private-sector jobs.

And while the new US administration has made it clear that Musk has simply been appointed as an advisor to the president, rather than becoming a federal employee, the high profile entrepreneur has nevertheless been given responsibility for overseeing the newly-created Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), which is charged with undertaking a fundamental root and branch reform of the federal government system.

Speaking in mid-April, Musk claimed that the cuts he was proposing to the federal government would save American taxpayers $150bn by 2026 by reducing “waste and fraud”.

Tariff spat

Musk’s high-profile role in the Trump administration was very much in evidence during the international furore created by the American president’s unilateral decision in April to impose wide-ranging global tariffs against countries deemed to be taking unfair trading advantage of the US.

As a businessman whose interests extend across the globe, including China—one of the countries heaviest hit by Trump’s tariff agenda—Musk had decidedly mixed feelings about the policy. It even prompted him to have a very public spat with Peter Navarro, Trump’s long-time trade adviser and a staunch supporter of Trump’s pro-tariff agenda. After Trump’s tariffs announcement prompted a global market self-off, Musk took aim at Navarro, calling him a “moron”.

Musk made his comments after Navarro made disparaging remarks about Musk after he called on the US to establish a “zero tariff” trading arrangement with Europe. Navarro—a long-time advocate of imposing tariffs to redress America’s trade balance with the rest of the world— was highly dismissive of Musk, who has extensive business dealings in Europe, denouncing him as a “car assembler” who was heavily dependent on importing car parts from overseas, and would thereby be badly hit by Trump’s tariffs policy.

Musk responded angrily, posting on X that, “Navarro is truly a moron. What he says here is demonstrably false. Tesla has the most American-made cars. Navarro is dumber than a sack of bricks.”

The highly public spat between two of Trump’s most prominent officials prompted an intervention by White House spokeswoman Karoline Leavitt, who remarked that these are obviously two individuals who have very different views on trade and on tariffs. Boys will be boys, and we will let their public sparring continue."

Trump’s subsequent decision to suspend most of the tariffs, except those directed at China, was later attributed to the arguments advanced by Musk and his supporters in the administration that the policy could prove counter-productive to American interests—especially after the implementation of the tariffs prompted sharp falls on Wall Street.

Trump’s decision to suspend his tariff regime certainly put a smile back on Musk’s face, as the Tesla owner enjoyed a $36bn increase in his wealth overnight as shares in companies such as Tesla soared.

Not surprisingly, Musk’s appointment to such a key position in the new Trump administration has not been without its critics, even prompting suggestions that he would soon stand down from his position—a rumour that was quickly rebuffed by the White House.

Even so, dozens of House Democrats insisted that Musk should leave his role in the administration by the end of May, arguing that the tech billionaire is only allowed to serve in his role as a special government employee for 130 days.

For now, the bromance holds between Trump and Musk, even though many Washington political insiders believe the relationship will ultimately end in tears

Conflict-of-interest concerns

One ongoing source of concern with Musk's position in the White House, for example, is that there is no evidence that he has obtained a conflict-of-interest waiver, meaning that he cannot exploit his privileged position to further his substantial business interests. Instead, Leavitt told NBC News, Musk has simply pledged he will avoid potential conflicts of interest and that, like all Trump-appointed "special government employees," he's "abiding by all applicable laws".

But after Musk's Starlink internet service became available at the White House, conflict of interest concerns have grown with each day Musk spends at the heart of government. Trump himself has been forced to clarify, for example, that Musk will not be shown plans for a hypothetical war with China because of his extensive business interests there.

"Elon has businesses in China, and he would be susceptible perhaps to that," Trump explained.

Moreover, Trump's redoubtable chief of staff, Susie Wiles, possibly sensing trouble ahead, has refused to grant Musk an office in the West Wing, despite Musk lobbying strongly for the privilege. Instead, Musk's DOGE team is based in the Eisenhower Executive Office Building, across the road from the White House.

Given that both Trump and Musk are renowned for their controversial public utterances, it is no surprise that the two billionaires have not always seen eye to eye.

"I don't hate the man," Musk tweeted in July 2022, "but it's time for Trump to hang up his hat & sail into the sunset." The comment was prompted by Trump calling Musk a liar. Then, Trump told a rally crowd in Alaska: "Elon is not going to buy Twitter." Musk did buy Twitter several months later and went on to endorse Trump's Republican arch-rival, Ron DeSantis.

Musk, who became a US citizen in 2002, has said that he voted almost exclusively for Democrats for decades. But he differed with President Joe Biden over issues including unions (Musk is opposed to efforts to organise his car workers) and over a snub when he was not invited to the 2021 White House electric vehicle summit, despite his company Tesla's status as one of the world's largest EV manufacturers.

Under the Biden administration, Musk's companies also faced several federal investigations over employment practices, his takeover of Twitter and claims about Tesla's autopilot feature. In November 2023, he told a New York Times interviewer that he would not vote for Biden again but stopped short of supporting Trump, saying, "This is definitely a difficult choice here."

Turning point

Musk began to align more with Trump's policies, including those on immigration and the US-Mexico border wall. "We actually do need a wall, and we need to require people to have some shred of evidence to claim asylum to enter, as everyone is doing that..." Musk wrote. However, Musk still would not donate to a candidate in the presidential election. It was the assassination attempt on Trump at a campaign rally in Pennsylvania that seemed to shift the dynamics of their relationship.

In October 2024, Musk and Trump made their first public appearance together at a campaign rally in Butler, Pennsylvania. Musk wore a Make America Great Again (MAGA) hat and publicly supported Trump in the presidential race.

A month later, Trump announced that Musk would lead the new Department of Government Efficiency to operate as an independent advisory group to cut government spending and streamline bureaucracy.

 Anna Moneymaker / AFP
Elon Musk wears a black "Make America Great Again" ball cap at a campaign rally with Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump at the Butler Farm Show Fairgrounds on October 5, 2024, in Butler, Pennsylvania.

Early life and career

Born in Pretoria, South Africa, Musk was accepted to a physics graduate degree programme at Stanford University, where he soon dropped out and founded two technology start-ups during the dotcom boom of the 1990s. These included a web software firm and an online banking company that eventually became PayPal, which was sold to eBay in 2002 for $1.5bn (£1.2bn).

Read more: Is apartheid South Africa to blame for Big Tech politics?

He ploughed his fortune into a new rocket company, SpaceX, which he aimed to make a cost-effective alternative to NASA, and a new electric car company, Tesla, where he chaired the board until becoming chief executive in 2008.

In the press, he's been called both a mad genius and Twitter's biggest troll, known as much for his fights— including one with British prime minister Sir Keir Starmer, calling him "complicit" in rape, not to mention the more serious lawsuits he and his companies have faced from regulators, investors and others over issues such as racial discrimination and the trustworthiness of his claims.

Divorced three times—twice from the same woman, British actress Talulah Riley—and father of 13 children, Musk is frank about his faults. "If you list my sins, I sound like the worst person on Earth, " he said in a TED interview in 2022. "But if you put those against the things I've done right, it makes much more sense."

Musk is now firmly entrenched as a key figure in the new Trump administration, recently attending a cabinet meeting wearing a new hat which said, "Trump is right about everything".

Even so, Musk's business interests have enjoyed mixed fortunes as a result of his support for Trump, with sales of new Tesla cars suffering a slump in Europe, as well as being vandalised, in the latest indication of a potential buyer backlash over Musk's high profile and controversial behaviour since becoming a leading figure in Donald Trump's administration.

For now, though, the bromance holds between Trump and Musk, even though many Washington political insiders believe the relationship will ultimately end in tears. For, as a Chinese saying doing the rounds in DC says: "Two tigers cannot live on one mountaintop."

font change