Algeria makes the case for a better EU trade deal

With Algeria's hand strengthened by its relatively new status as Europe’s leading gas supplier, economic experts say its poised to clinch a more favourable trade deal with its neighbour to the north

Algerian President Abdelmadjid Tebboune shakes hands with European Union Council President Charles Michel during their meeting, on September 5, 2022.
Council of the European Union
Algerian President Abdelmadjid Tebboune shakes hands with European Union Council President Charles Michel during their meeting, on September 5, 2022.

Algeria makes the case for a better EU trade deal

A 19-year-old economic partnership between Algeria and the European Union is due to be redrawn this year, but under very different circumstances than two decades ago when it was first agreed.

After a wave of economic development, Algeria has gained the confidence to put its national interests first and build more equitable partnerships. This bravado will come in handy when fresh talks between EU and Algerian trade delegations are set to begin this month.

Several technical meetings have already been pencilled into the 2025 calendar. Ahead of the meetings, Al Majalla offers an overview of Algeria's relationship with the major trading bloc on the opposite shore of the Mediterranean, looking at the ins and outs of the pact and why the country is now better placed than before to negotiate a better deal.

An unfair shake

Algeria first signed the agreement in 2002, when it was in a far weaker state. As Aboubaker Salami points out, the country was still reeling from a security crisis in the 1990s and its subsequent economic isolation from the world.

The deal was supposed to attract European investment and boost economic growth, but that never fully materialised. It envisaged the gradual liberalisation of trade in agricultural, agri-food, and fisheries products, as well as in the service sector. It set up a free trade zone for industrial products, but as customs barriers came down, import duties kept Algerian revenue down. Meanwhile, the expected inflow of investment never came.

AFP / FAYEZ NURELDINE
An Algerian fisherman prepares his fish net at the Lamadrack fish and touristy port in Algiers' Ain Bounian suburb.

This led to a revenue shortfall. Since the deal's enforcement in 2005 until 2022, revenue from import duties stood at $5.6bn, or around 700bn dinars in local currency. And while the total trade volume between the two countries reached $1tn, EU investment into Algeria stood at only $13bn and was mainly confined to the energy sector, specifically hydrocarbons. Meanwhile, most of these funds ($12bn) were repatriated back into the EU through profits.

The feeling in Algeria is that the deal lacked clarity and a clear timeline. Inward investment from the EU was primarily limited to the financial sector and banking services. According to Algeria’s Agency for Investment Promotion, there were 816 foreign investment projects between 2002 and 2019, with a total value of $19bn, or around 2.6tn dinars, creating around 132,000 local jobs.

But the agreement had unintended repercussions. It boosted smuggling, often facilitated by inflated import invoices, dubious external trade deals or corrupt practices.

When he was trade minister, Bakhti Belaïb noted that $18bn worth of funds were siphoned off annually through inflated import invoices. Large sums of foreign currency are believed to have been smuggled offshore between 2009 and 2019 during the presidency of the late Abdelaziz Bouteflika.

The deal also failed to remove obstacles for Algeria’s products entering foreign markets. Lingering regulations are still keeping Algerian imports from reaching European markets. Despite continuous complaints from Algeria, the deal has yet to be thoroughly reviewed, although some partial revisions have been made.

The 2002 deal was supposed to attract EU investment and boost economic growth, but that never fully materialised

Speaking to Al Majalla, economic expert Dr Houari Tigharsi says the EU has failed to honour its commitments under the deal while also holding back on sharing technology. He added, "Additionally, the free movement of capital hasn't achieved the level of balance as per the spirit of the agreement."

Stronger position

With a string of political and financial successes under its belt, Algeria is now in a stronger position to negotiate ahead of the talks. It is now a leading energy supplier to the EU, buoyed by the fact that Russian energy is not being imported into the EU at the levels it used to following its invasion of Ukraine.

Data published by the European statistics agency Eurostat reveals that Algeria surpassed Russia in October last year as the EU's primary energy supplier—up from third place before the war. Algeria's share of European gas imports reached 21.6% during that month, with export revenues rising from €1.1bn ($1.13bn) in September to €1.3bn ($1.34bn) in October of the current year.

Europe is dependent on gas for its energy supplies, which is expected to deepen, covering about 85% of its energy needs by 2030, according to international experts.  

AFP
European Union Energy Commissioner Kadri Simson and members of her delegation attend a meeting with Algerian Minister of Energy and Mines Mohamed Arkab and members of his government, on October 10, 2022 in Algiers.

Meanwhile, Algeria's state oil company, Sonatrach, is also exploring new hydrocarbon sites. Analysts have already expressed optimism that Algeria's changed circumstances can give it a better bargaining position in the upcoming talks.

"Algeria is better poised to leverage its successes to get a better deal," Salami told Al Majalla.

Comprehensive review

A committee appointed by Algeria's foreign ministry has been reviewing the agreement since late 2022, and in the run-up to the talks, the government has ordered a team of experts to conduct to line-by-line review of the pact.

A key point for review will be the trade aspects of the deal, with a detailed examination of the annexes and statistical data on trade exchanges in agricultural, industrial, and fisheries products since the agreement came into force.

Algeria's export of fruits and vegetables has experienced significant growth, particularly during the October-to-March period when production in some countries, such as Russia, declines during the winter season. This gives hope that better terms can be secured for its agriculture industry. 

Whether the deal will be revised or binned remains unclear. However, Dr Abdessamad Saoudi, professor of economics at the University of M'sila, predicts the agreement will likely be suspended until a better one, reflecting Algeria's changed circumstances, can be clinched.

"Fundamental aspects of the deal must be revised, especially regarding the free movement of goods and ensuring Algerian products aren't restricted," he told Al Majalla

He also said that instead of focusing purely on its hydrocarbon and petrochemical industries, Algeria's agricultural and industrial sectors deserve more attention.

font change