Many critics and viewers feel let down by the latest film in this DC Comics character franchise, with some even calling Joker: Folie à Deux a complete failure—in stark contrast to the widespread acclaim its predecessor, The Joker, got in 2019. The difference can be explained—at least in part—by the five-year wait for a follow-up, which focuses on the complex villain first seen in the Batman films. High expectations help explain the accompanying disappointment.
In industry circles, it is being seen as a significant misstep for its leading stars—Joaquin Phoenix and Lady Gaga—and its director, Todd Phillips, who also co-wrote the screenplay with Scott Silver. Underwhelmed critics say the film lacks coherence and vision and betrays the essence of the main character.
Meeting expectations
There is a feeling that the 2024 film lacks one of its predecessors' best qualities: the element of surprise. But this reaction comes from external factors and peripheral expectations rather than the film itself.
Unlike others in the franchise, the film is not heavily focused on spectacle and does not indulge in grand Hollywood theatrics. Those looking for an adrenaline rush will not find it here, so those expecting one will certainly feel let down. Part psychological thriller and part courtroom drama, it lacks the characteristics it was perhaps expected to include: those of a superhero blockbuster.