Gaza’s wartime exercises for a war that won’t happen

Vested interests in the status quo mean that this sorry cycle of violence and counter-violence between Israel and Palestinian factions will continue

Gaza’s wartime exercises for a war that won’t happen

The latest round of violence in Gaza and the West Bank shows how, for Palestinians, violence has become a fact-of-life.

At the time of writing, 33 people – mainly civilians – had been killed by Israeli airstrikes in the Gaza Strip, while in the town of Qmatiye near Jenin, two were killed in an Israeli military operation.

Dubbed ‘Operation Shield and Arrow’, this aggression is being depicted as another “war crime” by media outlets. If so, it will just be added to a long list of other atrocities, as Israel battles Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad (PIJ).

Gaza’s Groundhog Day

This latest clash appears to be more about “hearts and minds”, which suggests a decline in interest in this type of confrontation.

After calm is restored and life returns, the families of the dead are left to mourn their loved ones. It is a familiar scene.

Much that is happening has happened before: external parties broker a ceasefire, the Israeli prime minister warns enemies not to mess with “our security”, a new chapter is added to the tragedy of the Nakba, as its 75-year anniversary approaches.

Witnessing the killings and reactions without any meaningful commentary is disheartening, even from those who have made living from doing so. Still, it is unlikely that these bombings and deaths will further the Palestinian cause.

The lack of any meaningful commentary on the killings is disheartening, even from those who make living from doing so.

Palestinian leaders have failed to bridge the divisions within their ranks, lack a cohesive national programme, and often make unsubstantiated claims to compensate for their lack of tangible political achievements.

Palestinian attacks will likely continue, as will the bloody Israeli responses, in a perpetual cycle. It leaves all parties trapped in a vicious circle with no end in sight.

It appears to be a dress rehearsal for an all-out war that will never happen. Why? Because all sides – including Palestinian backers, such as the Iranian Revolutionary Guard - are too invested in the status quo to risk all-out conflict.

Entrenched on all sides

The grievances are deep. The Israeli occupation tears apart the Palestinian social fabric, hindering its stability both politically and economically, which in turn makes it difficult to institute Palestinian responses and goals.

Individual attacks, whether with knives, firearms, or vehicles, will continue targeting Israeli settlers and soldiers, while violent clashes in Gaza and the increasing role of new armed groups in the West Bank will become a constant feature.

Attacks with knives, guns, or cars targeting Israeli settlers and soldiers will continue, as will the violent clashes in Gaza.

The intensity may rise or fall depending on the actions of the occupation - settler movements, statements by Israeli right-wing hawks, attempts to storm the Al-Aqsa Mosque, and the assassinations of activists all risk escalation.

But any ebbs or flows will only have a marginal effect on the overall direction of travel. The profound and often-silent struggle of the Palestinians over the past two decades has many angles, security and armed conflict being just one.

Palestinians' fading hopes

As things stand, it appears that the dream of a two-state solution - the focal point of the peace process in the 1990s – may be coming to an end.

Likewise, establishing a dual Palestinian-Jewish state seems increasingly impossible too, due to the fear of Jewish assimilation into an expanding Palestinian population.

Caught between the unfeasibility of the two-state solution and the bi-national-state solution (if we agree that Jews are a nationality, as some have argued), the hope of the Palestinian cause continues to wane.

The powerbroker bureaucrats in Ramallah and the armed rulers of Gaza seem content in their isolation, despite holding millions hostage. Israel has no qualms about killing some of them when it sees fit.

Palestinian rulers seem content in their isolation, holding millions hostage, while Israel has no qualms about killing some when it sees fit.

Palestinians need to develop a comprehensive programme that addresses their own leaders' neglect before protesting the world's indifference and the perceived "Arab betrayal" of an issue that is no longer a central concern.

Without such a programme, they will continue to be vulnerable to Israeli policies that solidify the establishment of numerous settlements, the separation wall, and the implementation of restrictions such as crossings and bypass roads designed to hinder Palestinian interaction.

This gradual but steady accumulation of circumstances is leading towards a shift in the balance of power. It is clear that this shift may not favour the Palestinians and may not culminate in a ceremony in the White House garden akin to the one marking the signing of the Oslo Accords nearly three decades ago.

font change