Pope Leo is right to warn about AI and the ambitions of Big Tech

The pontiff urges better oversight of a technology that will define the future, given its control by a small group of company leaders with some unpalatable views of the world.

Pope Leo is right to warn about AI and the ambitions of Big Tech

Arab interest in artificial intelligence (AI) at present seems largely confined to how it can best generate profits, whether by improving corporate performance and investment opportunities or through security and military applications. Yet such a focus overlooks the more dangerous dimensions of this technology and its effects on the broader structures of state, society, and economy.

In recent months, the heads of major technology companies such as Amazon, Tesla, and Palantir have contributed to the debate over what AI means from their perspective. Issues range from the role of humans in a world run by non-human intelligence to the right to work and the end of society as we know it, in the form it has taken since the agricultural revolution thousands of years ago. In between, the discussion has covered power, democracy, governance, and financial elites.

At the most recent World Economic Forum in Davos, Elon Musk—the world’s richest man and owner of SpaceX, Tesla, and X—painted a rosy picture of a future in which the fusion of AI and robotics would open “horizons of abundance”, while consciousness would spread through space thanks to SpaceX’s projects, in a universe where consciousness and life are exceedingly rare. Most people, meanwhile, would no longer have to work, thanks to wealth produced by machines and distributed among citizens.

Notably, Musk declared his support for the extremist Restore Britain group, which he said was “the only one that will save Britain,” and funded the Unite the Kingdom demonstrations organised by activist Tommy Robinson, whom several British media outlets accuse of racism.

Tax and rights

Jeff Bezos, founder of Amazon, recently launched a fierce attack on the tax policies of left-wing New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani after he proposed taxing major corporations (like Amazon) after Republican laws and exemptions had sharply reduced the tax burden on such companies. Bezos argued that the system advocated by Mamdani was a failure and that the employment offered by Amazon was more useful and beneficial than collecting taxes from the wealthy.

Musk painted a rosy picture of a future in which the fusion of AI and robotics would open "horizons of abundance"

Alex Karp, co-founder of the software and data analytics company Palantir, is clear in his embrace of a vision of a world run and governed by advanced technology companies. He has been openly hostile to those who demand equality and rights while deriding those who criticise the genocide in Gaza, calling it "the killing of terrorists". He is proud that Israel's intelligence agencies and armed forces use Palantir technology.

To some, there is a convergence among the heads of 'big tech' in supporting populist and far-right forces in the US and Europe, one that suggests that the Orwellian notion of an all-seeing 'Big Brother' governance system typically invoked in dystopian literature may turn out to be the owner of a technology company, not a dictator.

Ethical framework

In this context, the struggle over the role of AI and its relationship to human society has yet to be settled, which brings us to the recent open message addressed by Pope Leo XIV to the world under the title Wonderful Humanity. By any measure, this was an important step in establishing an ethical framework for the use of AI and identifying the pitfalls that major companies must avoid.

The message appears to continue the approach of his predecessor, Pope Francis, who twice warned of the danger of climate change and the disasters whose human cause—and whose continued neglect—would have such grave consequences for humanity. Throughout, Leo's message reads almost like a direct response to the arguments advanced by the heads of these major companies.

He advocates strengthening the role of governments to oversee companies developing AI, protecting the rights of employees and workers threatened by this technology, encouraging students to adopt critical thinking towards it, and preventing social media platforms from turning into platforms for hatred and incitement to violence.

At the beginning of the millennium, there were similar warnings about the dangers of genetic engineering and cloning, as scientists made rapid progress mapping the human genome. It raises hopes of finding cures for some intractable diseases, but also generated legitimate alarm that these techniques might be exploited to create human 'mutants' for all manner of activities. A similar tendency is emerging today in the cautious treatment of the unchecked and poorly regulated expansion of AI. The dreams promoted by companies chasing exorbitant profits may be the first step into the abyss.

font change