Turning tides? Israel's allies are finally criticising its war on Gaza

Terms like "genocide" and "cruel and indefensible" are finally being used by Western leaders to describe Israel's military and starvation campaign in Gaza. Have they finally had enough?

Turning tides? Israel's allies are finally criticising its war on Gaza

Having defied world opinion since the start of its uncompromising military campaign in Gaza, Israel suddenly finds itself under mounting international pressure to address the appalling suffering being experienced by Palestinian civilians.

When Israel first launched its war on Gaza in the wake of the October 7 attacks carried about by Hamas, the overwhelming body of world opinion was firmly behind Israel. That support has waned over the course of Israel's 18-month campaign, but key Western states like the US, UK, France and Germany have refrained from taking substantial measures to curb its behaviour, despite Israel nearly flattening the entire Gaza Strip and killing more than 50,000 Palestinians.

It even led to the International Court of Justice and the International Criminal Court censuring Israel and its leaders, but such verdicts by top world courts have done little to curtail Israel's actions on the ground.

Criticisms have intensified since Israel renewed hostilities in Gaza after it broke a ceasefire agreement earlier this year that resulted in a number of Israeli and Palestinian hostages being swapped, and Israel coming under pressure to let much-needed aid enter Gaza.

But since it broke the ceasefire, Israel has imposed a total blockade on the Strip on 2 March, with aid and human rights organisations warning that hundreds of thousands of Palestinians in Gaza are facing starvation after Israel. Up until recently, no aid has entered, including food, water, medical supplies and equipment.

Call to 'prevent genocide'

The forced starvation campaign has sparked an international outcry, with United Nations aid chief Tom Fletcher calling on the UN Security Council to act decisively to “prevent genocide” from taking place in Gaza. During a briefing to the Security Council, Fletcher, who is responsible for maintaining aid supplies to Gaza, asked, “Will you act decisively to prevent genocide and to ensure respect for international humanitarian law?" He also said if aid doesn't get in immediately, 14,000 Palestinian babies could die in 48 hours.

Israel has repeatedly denied it is committing genocide, despite Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich vowing to “conquer” and “cleanse" Gaza. In a statement on Monday, he said that Israel's goal was to "destroy everything that’s left of the Gaza Strip."

We are disassembling Gaza, and leaving it as piles of rubble, with total destruction (which has) no precedent globally

Israeli Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich

"Our best friends in the world—senators I know as strong supporters of Israel—have warned that they cannot support us if images of mass starvation emerge," he said. "We must avoid famine, both for practical reasons and diplomatic ones. Without international backing, we won't be able to complete the mission of victory."

"Truth be told, until the last of the hostages returns, we should also not let water into the Gaza Strip. But the reality is that if we do that, the world will force us to halt the war immediately, and to lose," Smotrich said. "We are disassembling Gaza, and leaving it as piles of rubble, with total destruction (which has) no precedent globally."

Toughest criticisms yet

Yet, judging by the growing unease among Western leaders at Israel's obstinacy, Western allies who have previously been staunch supporters of the Jewish state are voicing their toughest criticisms yet. This week, Canada, France and the UK joined forces to warn Israel that they will take "concrete actions" if it continues with its "egregious" expansion of military operations in the enclave. In a joint statement, the three countries' three leaders called on the Israeli government to "stop its military operations" and "immediately allow humanitarian aid to enter Gaza".

British Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer, Canadian Premier Mark Carney and French President Emmanuel Macron publicly condemned Israel's policies in Gaza, declaring the "denial of essential humanitarian assistance to the civilian population is unacceptable and risks breaching International Humanitarian Law". They added that the level of suffering in Gaza was "intolerable".

They also condemned "the abhorrent language used recently by members of the Israeli Government, threatening that, in their despair at the destruction of Gaza, civilians will start to relocate".

"Permanent forced displacement is a breach of international humanitarian law," they added. "We have always supported Israel's right to defend Israelis against terrorism. But this escalation is wholly disproportionate.*

Further evidence that world leaders are becoming increasingly angered by Israel's approach to the Gaza conflict emerged after the UK announced it was suspending talks on a free-trade deal with Israel and announced sanctions against West Bank settlers.

Read more: Israel under mounting international pressure to let aid into Gaza

We condemn the abhorrent language used recently by members of the Israeli Government, stating that residents will start to relocate out of despair from Gaza's destruction

Joint statement by UK, France and Canada

At the same time, the UK Foreign Office summoned Israel's ambassador to raise its concerns. British Foreign Secretary David Lammy confirmed that the government was also considering imposing sanctions on ministers, saying: "We keep these issues under review." The UK's Middle East Minister Hamish Falconer will also tell the Israeli ambassador to the UK, Hotovely, that "the 11-week block on aid to Gaza has been cruel and indefensible", Lammy added.

UK officials said they were drawing up plans with other countries to impose sanctions on Smotrich, Itamar Ben-Gvir, the national security minister, and Israel Katz, the defence minister, among others.

Lammy condemned as "monstrous" calls from Israeli cabinet ministers for Gaza to be cleansed, describing the comments as repellent and extremist.

He said Israel's refusal to allow thousands of aid lorries into Gaza was an "affront to the values of the British people" and accused the government of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of "isolating Israel from its friends and partners around the world". Lammy's comments represent Britain's strongest condemnation of Israel since the war with Hamas started in 2023.

The European Union is also to review a pact governing its political and economic ties with Israel due to the "catastrophic" situation in Gaza, the EU's top diplomat, Kaja Kallas, said after a meeting of the bloc's foreign ministers. A clear majority of EU member states have backed a Dutch proposal to review the bloc's trade deal with Israel. For his part, Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez has said his country doesn't trade with a "genocidal state".

A frustrated Trump

And, in a sign of the increasing international pressure on Israel to end hostilities in Gaza, even US President Donald Trump, a staunch supporter of Israel, is reportedly growing frustrated by what he sees as Israel's refusal to end the war. While the White House is reluctant to criticise the Israelis in public, Trump is said to have told his officials he expects Netanyahu to "wrap up" the war. The president is said to believe the distress in Gaza has reached unacceptable levels and has been upset by images of children suffering.

For the moment, the Netanyahu government remains defiant, insisting it will continue with its military offensive to destroy Hamas. But if international pressure continues to mount, Netanyahu may soon find he has no alternative but to call a halt to hostilities.

font change