The quest for utopia: Will Arabs ever learn their lesson?

It's not wrong to strive toward utopia. But it is also important to understand that historically, "promised paradises" often culminate in disaster and suffering

The quest for utopia: Will Arabs ever learn their lesson?

Arabs have all sorts of aspirations, ranging from the liberation of Palestine to Arab unity from the "roaring ocean to the rebelling Gulf," a slogan popularised in the 1960s.

The Islamic State (IS) harboured ambitions to conquer Rome; others call to rectify the "big mistake" of Mustafa Kemal Ataturk's abolition of the Muslim caliphate, as evidenced by a banner recently spotted in a European capital that said, "The caliphate is the solution", according to The European Conservative.

It's not wrong to strive toward utopia. In fact, it is comforting to believe that a better and brighter future—away from a grim, challenging, and monotonous present—is possible.

Indeed, many political ideologies have had a profound impact throughout human history. But it is also important to be realistic and understand that historically, such "promised paradises" often culminate in disaster and suffering.

From the Third Reich, who vowed to secure peace and happiness for the German people "for a thousand years" through the occupation of Lebensraum, deemed essential for its ambitions, to the forced relocation of Cambodians to the countryside by the Khmer Rouge under Pol Pot to Mao Zedong's "Great Leap Forward"—none ended well.

The problem is when people misunderstand the forces influencing present-day events, This skews perceptions of what can realistically be achieved.

As German philosopher Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel famously noted, history plays a "cunning" role in this process. It conceals major surprises and upheavals behind the monotony of expected events and the dull succession of countless days devoid of anything new.

This can lead people to believe that nothing will change unless radical and swift action is taken without understanding their full consequences and impact.

It's not wrong to strive toward utopia. But it is also important to understand that historically, such "promised paradises" often culminate in disaster and suffering.

Arabs have learned this lesson the hard way. Failed experiments, irreparable losses, and catastrophic wars, along with the prisons, detention centres, exiles, and destruction they engendered, have pushed us further away from utopia.

Oftentimes, critiques and reviews of events—recent or historical—are often met with accusations of treason or apostasy. They fail to realise that our present is a direct result of a series of smaller details that have collectively shaped it.

Without allowing such debates and critiques to take place, we run the risk of repeating past mistakes in both times of war and peace. This applies uniformly to topics such as Palestine or Arab governments' dealings with their respective populations—from Sudan to Syria to Yemen.

We seem to be living in a perpetual and vicious state of déjà vu where we keep repeating the same mistakes and incurring their subsequent costs. New generations continue demonstrating, demanding, and echoing the familiar chants of previous generations, but nothing seems to be changing.

What is worse is no one takes the blame or responsibility for these mistakes amid the cries of Gaza's children being slaughtered by Israel and the growing displacement in Sudan. Instead, some groups seem bent on dragging the region into an endless cycle of violence and death.

Will we ever be able to break this cycle? This is the million-dollar question. There are many possible exit ramps. The first step is to understand the limitations of reality.

font change