Shenzhen meet: a 'great success', despite deep divides

China and Russia tout their growing partnership in Shenzhen, while Trump tries to shore up his image broad after suffering a humiliating midterm loss back home

Shenzhen meet: a 'great success', despite deep divides

If some of the expectations raised by the historic summit involving the leaders of China, Russia and the US may prove to be unrealistic, the possibility nevertheless remains that it could ultimately have a profound impact on how the world’s leading powers address key global security issues.

There was certainly no shortage of hyperbole as Chinese President Xi Jinping welcomed US President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin for a trilateral summit held on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) in the Chinese city of Shenzhen.

As the meeting began—the first-ever to be held between the leaders of three of the world’s major powers—Xi said the talks had “groundbreaking significance”, while Trump declared the three leaders were “really making history”. For his part, Putin said he expected a big “benefit” to come from the meeting, and suggested Russia, China and the US shared a “joint responsibility” for maintaining global security.

Although the summit involving the three leaders was only scheduled to last an hour, they nevertheless set an ambitious agenda, with key subjects such as the wars in Ukraine and Iran, nuclear disarmament, and trade topping the list.

A four-point communique, titled a “joint declaration of peace”, issued by the three leaders following the conclusion of the talks said the trio would commit to pushing for reform of the United Nations so that it "may respond more effectively to global challenges and fulfil its fundamental mission of maintaining international peace and security".

The trio agreed to increase the production of refined oil products "for the benefit of all nations", despite the international sanctions that still apply to Russian oil sales.

Reference was also made to limiting the scope of the International Criminal Court to “abuse” its position by pursuing state officials, while the leaders agreed to engage in a dialogue over nuclear proliferation on the basis that "nuclear war must not be fought".

Putin referred to Xi as his "dear friend", claiming that cooperation between Russia and China was on the rise."

Specific issues

But while the historic summit between the three leaders inevitably dominated the headlines, of equal importance was the opportunity the summit provided for the leaders to have a series of bilateral discussions aimed at resolving specific issues.

Trump's talks with Putin, for example, were the first time the American and Russian leaders had met since their inconclusive summit in Alaska in August 2025, when Trump hoped to persuade the Russians to accept a ceasefire in the long-running Ukraine conflict. After initially indicating he was willing to consider a ceasefire, Putin ultimately failed to deliver.

Despite that setback, Trump clearly remains confident that it might still be possible to persuade Putin to agree to a deal to end the war in Ukraine, even if some of the concessions the Trump administration may require from Kyiv could prove unpalatable to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky.

Trump continues to believe he has a special rapport with Putin, and has rejected recent attempts to impose new sanctions against Moscow in the belief that it could encourage the Russian leader to do a deal. Ukraine has also complained that the US has deliberately disrupted its satellite support for its drone operations as a way of increasing the pressure on Kyiv to end the war.

Speaking after his 40-minute face-to-face meeting with Putin, whom the American president called "my friend", Trump declared, "Wonderful things can come out of this —or at least start. We've had a great relationship for many years."

It remains to be seen whether Trump's faith in Putin to deliver peace in Ukraine is justified, especially as the Russian leader used his own bilateral meeting with Xi to bolster military cooperation between Russia and China.

China's support for Russia has proved to be crucial since Putin launched his so-called "special military operation" against Ukraine in February 2022, with Western governments accusing the Asian superpower of supporting the Kremlin's wartime economy and its defence industry, as well as helping the Kremlin avoid international sanctions.

Dmitry ‌Shugayev, head ⁠of Russia's service for ⁠military-technical cooperation, said Moscow and Beijing had reached a "new level" of partnership

Closer than ever

Putin's decision to arrive in China before Trump meant he was able to secure a face-to-face meeting with the Chinese leader before the summit began in earnest on Thursday. Following two hours of private talks between Putin and Xi, it was announced that their two countries would pursue projects to build aircraft, air defence and naval and space technologies.

Dmitry ‌Shugayev, head ⁠of Russia's service for ⁠military-technical cooperation, said the countries had reached a "new level" of partnership. The Russian president said both Moscow and Beijing were taking "constructive approaches to shaping a more equitable, multipolar world order", in remarks seen as a challenge to American dominance.

To underline the importance of the relationship, Putin referred to Xi as his "dear friend", claiming that cooperation between Russia and China was on the rise." Their relationship was as "steadfast as a rock through wind and rain", Putin added.

Iran is another issue where Trump will struggle to reach common ground with Putin and Xi, as both Russia and China have continued to provide assistance to Tehran. Following the Republicans' disastrous showing in the recent midterm elections, Trump is known to be keen to do a deal to end the Iran war. To this end, he has implemented a punishing sanctions regime against Tehran in the hope of forcing the ayatollahs to agree to a permanent peace deal.

But the Trump administration's efforts to force Tehran to agree to its terms for ending the war, which include the complete reopening of the Strait of Hormuz and ending Iran's nuclear programme, are being undermined by the support provided by both Russia and Iran to Tehran. China, in particular, is continuing to purchase significant quantities of Iranian oil, thereby throwing the ayatollahs an economic lifeline.

So while, on the surface, the statements issued by the three leaders following their historic summit seek to claim the meeting has been a great success, there are still many important issues, such as Ukraine and Iran, where the three leaders have deeply opposing agendas.

font change