Basel Adra: I wanted to make a film as disturbing as my reality

Speaking to Al Majalla, the Palestinian co-director of Best Documentary winner 'No Other Land' says he believes that solidarity with Gaza’s suffering was a factor in his film’s Oscars success

Basel Adra
GettyImages
Basel Adra

Basel Adra: I wanted to make a film as disturbing as my reality

When he first picked up a video camera, Hebron-born Palestinian activist Basel Adra had no idea that it would take him, his cause, and his land to one of the world’s most influential platforms for visual storytelling, a ceremony viewed by 19.7 million Americans and many more around the globe.

Through experimentation and passion, he found a way to create impact, defend his homeland, share the story of his people in the villages of Masafer Yatta, south of Hebron, and document their experience of ethnic cleansing and assault by the occupation.

The documentary he helped make with three other activists, called No Other Land, marked the first-ever Palestinian presence at the Academy Awards, following the film’s victory at the Berlin International Film Festival. Israeli journalist Yuval Abraham co-directed it with Adra, Hamdan Ballal (a Palestinian) and Rachel Szor (an Israeli). This gave the impression that the film was a joint Palestinian-Israeli production. Al Majalla spoke to Adra about this and more.


What do you think it was about No Other Land that set it apart from the competition at the Oscars?

It seems that what we managed to achieve as a team was to present a living, breathing narrative, through sound, movement, and human presence. We brought to life the scenes of ethnic cleansing and the systematic abuse of Palestinians in Masafer Yatta by Israeli settlers and soldiers.

It also appears that we succeeded in opening Western eyes to our reality. For the first time, a Palestinian story was showcased on the Oscars stage to a global audience. The West has long adopted the Israeli narrative, so for the first time we were able to present a Palestinian perspective—one of daily oppression and suffering.

AFP
Basel Adra and Yuval Abraham at the Oscars

What motivated you to make this film?

Since I was a teenager, I always felt a duty to tell the story of Masafer Yatta. It is a small village in the Hebron governorate, but even some Palestinians don't know about it because the media rarely sheds light on our story.

Masafer Yatta is part of Area C, which, according to the Oslo II Accords, means that it is under full Israeli security control. In practice, this means that residents are subjected to harsh living conditions, relentless persecution, and constant threats of displacement.

We face daily assaults and unchecked lawlessness. Facing this relentless injustice, we had no choice but to resist. In this, we were supported by leftist Israeli activists who recognised our right to live on our land and documented the injustices we endured, through numerous investigative reports.

I also realised that by using my camera, I could document what my people were experiencing. It was like developing a third eye—one that could convey my emotions and thoughts to a wider audience. I wanted to communicate with the world, in my own way. Perhaps that is also what caught the Academy’s attention—a tangible, authentic story filled with raw moments that audiences could connect with.

What were the main challenges you and your team faced making this film?

The most pressing challenge was the location. It is exhausting and unsettling to live in a place constantly subjected to raids, inspections, vandalism, and chaos at the hands of Israeli settlers and soldiers. It is all part of a systematic plan to drive us off our land.

A scene from 'No Other Land'

One of the greatest difficulties was hiding our cameras from Israeli settlers intent on destruction. Our cameras were frequently damaged or confiscated. It took us longer than usual to make the film because many scenes were lost and had to be reshot due to the frequent raids by Israeli soldiers and settlers.

Sometimes, we had to pause our editing to confront settlers. We worked under brutal conditions, constantly at risk of persecution. I have been beaten and assaulted by Israeli settlers and soldiers. I have also been arrested multiple times for holding my camera and defending my village. I never wavered. The road ahead is long, but not impossible.

How did the real-life experiences featured in the film help convey the story in the most powerful way?

We aimed to make the scenes feel as though they were unfolding in real time—capturing the essence of life in Masafer Yatta. The voices, the cries, the shouts, and even the words of soldiers and settlers—all were integral to our storytelling. We wanted the audience to hear homes being demolished, of raids taking place. The film had to be as disturbing as our reality.

The use of multiple cameras during filming served a larger purpose. It was not just about capturing the Palestinian perspective but also the perspectives of Israelis, Germans, Americans, among others. We sought to showcase different angles, diverse viewpoints, through a multicultural lens. We left space for audiences from all backgrounds, religions, and ethnicities to interpret the scenes on their own.

We wanted the audience to hear homes being demolished, of raids taking place. The film had to be as disturbing as our reality.

Palestinian filmmaker Basel Adra

Some have criticised the participation of Yuval Abraham as a form of cultural normalisation. How do you respond?

I can't stop anyone from expressing their opinion and I don't find the debate troubling. Every film is set within a context, like reality itself. No Other Land took shape gradually, as Israeli activists Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor became involved in defending the people of Masafer Yatta and other areas.

They stood with us, faced danger alongside us, and helped us document and resist the settlers and soldiers threatening our land. Yes, they were partners in this project. Their presence helped amplify our story and bring the often-overlooked Palestinian narrative to the fore. I don't know whether this exposure will ultimately strengthen the Palestinian narrative, but I've fulfilled part of my artistic mission.

What matters to me above all is remaining on my land. Throughout this journey, we encountered much terminology and theoretical debate, most of which is disconnected from reality and does not reflect what is happening on the ground. 

During your acceptance speech, you only mentioned Masafer Yatta, and did not speak about the genocide in Gaza. What is your response to that?

I apologise to Gaza and its people for not delivering a specific message about the genocide in my acceptance speech. The committee gave us just 40 seconds. Contrary to some claims, this was without instruction or restriction.

I had to say something encapsulating our experience and success, which was hard to do in such a brief window. People often expect artists to turn into political leaders on stage, which is not a realistic demand. By highlighting the ethnic cleansing taking place in Masafer Yatta it offered a microcosm of the ongoing oppression faced by all Palestinians.

After all, you cannot summarise 80 years of suffering under occupation in 40 seconds. On-stage, overwhelmed and anxious, I struggled to fit everything in. That said, I have spoken about Gaza multiple times during previous award ceremonies and in discussions following the film's screenings, including in Germany (after No Other Land won at the Berlin International Film Festival).

I have said clearly what is happening in Gaza is ethnic cleansing. I also believe that the Oscar win for No Other Land was, in part, linked to the global solidarity with the people of Gaza, in addition to the universal significance that the Palestinian cause now has.

What can art convey in the face of genocide in Gaza and the West Bank, as well as ethnic cleansing in Masafer Yatta and other areas at the hands of Israel?

There is always something that can be said. Take Yuval Abraham's speech on the Oscars stage, where he spoke about how he and I are afforded different rights under Israeli occupation. That was a message—albeit a subtle one, but this is the language of art.

Art offers space for understanding, for analysing, and for shaping opinions. Its power lies in the fact that it does not wield weapons or engage in shouting matches. Art has always existed and will always exist, speaking to both minds and hearts, preserving the stories of people that would otherwise fade with time.

It can be disheartening to feel your work doesn't have a tangible impact, but we have no choice but to keep trying to create whatever impact we can

Palestinian filmmaker Basel Adra

What is the role of art amidst the harsh conditions that Palestinians face?

I know that artistic discourse and all the means through which it reaches audiences often seem less impactful than political rhetoric and military machinery. Gaza has been annihilated and its people displaced, yet the world's stance is unchanged in the face of these bloodbaths.

While I was receiving awards at festivals, the war on Gaza was intensifying, with genocide and ethnic cleansing. It was jarring to receive an award as US President Donald Trump was calling for the forced expulsion of my people from Gaza. This was the world's most powerful nation advocating ethnic cleansing and the systematic stripping away of people's rights.

It can sometimes be disheartening to feel your work doesn't have a tangible impact, but we have no choice but to keep trying to strike a chord and create whatever impact we can. In that sense, the role of art is to expand public awareness and stir emotions toward a cause.

What are your artistic plans moving forward?

I don't know. The Oscars were the most significant moment of my life. Now, I must return to reality, once again confronting settlers and soldiers to defend my land. I'm not sure what my future artistic endeavours will be.

I succeeded in one. Now I feel I need to build on that success, but I have not yet considered my next step. Perhaps I will remain in documentary cinema or find another cinematic space.

font change