Is US warning to Israel genuine or a campaign push for Harris?

With just three weeks to go before the US presidential election, many critics see the letter as too little, too late

Is US warning to Israel genuine or a campaign push for Harris?

The ultimatum issued by the Biden administration to Israel, warning that military supplies will be cut if the flow of humanitarian aid to Gaza is not improved within 30 days, may reflect the White House’s deepening frustration with the Israelis’ conduct of the war. But it is unlikely to make any material difference to the uncompromising military tactics Israel has adopted since last year’s October 7 attacks.

In what amounts to the most direct criticism the Biden administration has directed towards Israel since the Hamas attacks, a letter written by US Secretary of State Antony Blinken and Defence Secretary Lloyd Austin has provided a detailed criticism of Israel’s policy of blocking aid to Gaza.

In the letter, which was subsequently leaked to the Israeli media, Blinken and Austin provide a line-by-line dissection of Israel’s obstruction of aid deliveries—and the way its forcible relocation of civilians has exposed 1.7 million Palestinians to serious risk of disease.

Addressed to Israeli Defence Minister Yoav Gallant and Strategic Affairs Minister Ron Dermer, the US officials lamented the fact that the past several months have seen a significant deterioration in the amount of aid entering Gaza.

While they acknowledged that Israel had implemented a series of provisions to improve the flow of aid into Gaza after promising to do so in the spring, “the amount of aid delivered has (since) dropped by more than 50%,” Blinken and Austin wrote. Consequently, the amount of aid entering Gaza in September was the lowest of any month during the past year.

“To reverse the downward humanitarian trajectory and consistent with its assurances to us, Israel must—starting now and within 30 days—act on the following concrete measures,” they wrote. They also registered the “US government's deep concern over the deteriorating humanitarian situation in Gaza”.

Perhaps the most worrying aspect from Israel’s point of view was the American officials’ assertion that, by impeding the flow of aid to Gaza, some of which is donated by the US, the Israelis were in breach of US laws that restrict arms transfers to countries that block the distribution of American aid.

With just three weeks to go before the US presidential election, many critics see the letter as too little, too late

As a consequence, the failure of Israel to implement significant improvements to the humanitarian situation in Gaza within the next 30 days could result in Washington curbing future weapons supplies to Israel.

'Complete siege'

Israel's policy of imposing tight restrictions on humanitarian aid deliveries to Gaza stems from the Israeli government's initial response to the October 7 attacks, when Gallant announced that Israel intended to implement a "complete siege" of the Gaza Strip. No fuel or food would be allowed in, he said. "Everything is closed... We are fighting human animals, and we are acting accordingly."

The Biden administration had made several attempts to persuade the Israelis to adopt a more measured approach to aid deliveries, even though humanitarian agencies insist the amount of aid being delivered to the enclave remains wholly inadequate. Concern has grown in Washington in recent months that, despite Israel's promise to ease the flow of aid, restrictions have tightened, prompting Blinken and Austin to write their joint letter.

The Biden administration's mounting frustration with the Israelis stems from the fact that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has consistently undermined Washington's efforts to implement a ceasefire in Gaza.

There are also concerns in the White House that, following the launch of Israel's military offensive in Lebanon against Iranian-backed Hezbollah militants, Israel may be deliberately trying to draw the US into a direct confrontation with Iran.

Scant regard

Another issue that irks the Biden administration is that Israel appears to have paid scant regard to a memorandum issued by President Joe Biden earlier this year, which required allies that receive military aid from the US to provide  "credible and reliable written assurances" of their adherence to international law including international human rights law.

Responding to the letter, an Israeli official in Washington told The Times of Israel, which originally broke the story about the letter,  that Jerusalem was reviewing the issues raised by the Biden administration. "Israel takes this matter seriously and intends to address the concerns raised in this letter with our American counterparts," the official said.

The letter's 13 November deadline to Israel means no action will be taken before the US election result is known

But with just three weeks to go before the US presidential election, many critics see the latest attempt by the Biden administration to persuade the Israelis to comply with its demands as too little, too late.

Although the joint Blinken/Austin letter was sent before the election, its 13 November deadline means no action will be taken before the contest's result is known.

Campaign tactic

There have also been complaints that the White House's belated effort to persuade Israel to ease aid restrictions in Gaza is little more than a blatant attempt to help Vice-President Kamala Harris's faltering campaign, with the Democrats struggling to respond to calls from pro-Palestinian activists in the US to take a harder line against Netanyahu's government.

Certainly, while the letter has had the desired effect of prompting Israel to ease restrictions on Gaza, with the first aid supplies in two weeks reported to have entered the enclave, there are no indications that Israel has any intention of scaling down its military activities in Gaza and Lebanon.

Israel's defiant attitude towards the Biden administration is evident from the intensification of the Israeli army's operations in southern Lebanon, where a senior Hezbollah battalion commander was reported to have been "eliminated" by an Israeli attack this week.

Israeli military officials claimed that Hussein Muhammad Awada had been overseeing rocket attacks on Israel from multiple locations within the Bint Jbeil district. A wave of Israeli air strikes has also resulted in the deaths of 45 Hezbollah militants, while 50 Palestinians were reported killed during the latest wave of Israeli strikes in Gaza.

And, with Netanyahu insisting Israel intends to carry out its retaliatory attack against Iran before November's presidential poll, all the indications are that Biden's belated attempt to persuade Israel to show some restraint has little chance of success.

font change