How Arab writers are finally embracing the crime fiction genre

Once sniffed at as suitable only for children’s theatre, authors in the Arab world are now discovering how a murder can help set the scene. Al Majalla looks at four great recent examples.

Arabic writers are finally discovering a genre that has been well-loved for centuries
Arabic writers are finally discovering a genre that has been well-loved for centuries

How Arab writers are finally embracing the crime fiction genre

Crime and police thrillers have long appealed to both new and established writers. The genre offers a tried-and-tested template into which the author can weave their own characters and plotline.

It is a crowded field for good reason: its worldwide popularity. Readers have always enjoyed trying to work out who the perpetrator is, based on suspected motives and opportunity.

The ‘whodunnit’ has made literary stars out of the likes of Agatha Christie, Arthur Conan Doyle, and Georges Simenon, but until recently, the genre had never really caught on in the Arab world. That appears to be changing.

Judging by some of their recent output, Arab authors seem to have turned to crime writing. For decades, it was seen as something for youth literature, dismissed by critics.

Recent crime novels have caught attention for their high literary standards, with a mastery of language together with a skilled depiction of settings, societies, and eras. Al Majalla looks at four good examples.

Publication Ban

In Publication Ban by novelist and screenwriter Haitham Dabbour (2021), we are taken back in history to one of the most famous of all murder tales: One Thousand and One Nights, or Arabian Nights as it is often called in English.

This follows the king, Shahryar, whose wife is flagrantly unfaithful. He has her killed, then marries a virgin, only to have killed in the morning, so she cannot be unfaithful to him. This continues, with a new virgin wife killed every day, until there are few left.

His aide’s daughter Scheherazade offers herself as Shahryar’s next wife and saves her life through storytelling. Before they go to sleep, she tells Shahryar a story but does not end it.

He wants to hear the end, so does not kill her. The next night, she finishes the story and starts another, but does not end that one either. And so it goes on, for 1,001 nights.

Publication Ban links this ancient and captivating narrative with a contemporary crime of harassment involving a minister and a senior state official.

'Publication Ban' by Haitham Dabbour (Dar Al-Shorouk, 2021)

Unlike the traditional ‘who-did-it’ crime format, Dabbour’s novel identifies the perpetrator from the very first lines, then follows the repercussions and responses to this crime and how it is confronted.

Mona, a secretary and victim, faces this crime supported by her father and fiancé. Dabbour draws a parallel between Scheherazade (and her means of escaping death) and Mona, whose voice is being silenced by those around her out of fear of scandal.

The 'whodunnit' made literary stars out of Agatha Christie, Arthur Conan Doyle, and Georges Simenon, but never really caught on in the Arab world.

Mona's is a society obsessed with appearances, professing adherence to ethical and religious values but instead practising hypocrisy, abusing power, and violating sanctities. In such a society, such a scandal could kill Mona socially.

Between the two stories, Dabbour includes a third narrative concerning the publication of the manuscript of Arabian Nights itself, detailing the numerous attacks and censorship it faced due to its strong representation of freedom.

This begins with its first story which challenges norms and conventions, tackling taboo subjects like sex, religion, and rulers, addressing the relationship between men and women, and discussing myths and legends.

The journey of publishing and discovering the tales of Arabian Nights therefore becomes another adventure, the author tracing its path from then until now.

The Cinnamon Lady

Rahma Diaa transports us to the world of culinary delights in her novel The Cinnamon Lady (2024). The protagonist's father, a famous chef called Tawfiq, is discovered to have been murdered during the autopsy.

His daughter Mimmi overcomes the shock of the news and goes through her father's letters, uncovering secrets about his life. The reader goes with her on this journey, until the culprit is revealed.

'The Cinnamon Lady' by Rahma Diaa (Dar Al-Shorouk, 2024)

The novel focuses more on the exceptional relationship between Mimmi and her father than on the murder itself. Her mother, who has been absent, reappears after Tawfik's death, only to reveal that Mimmi has a half-sister. Mimmi learns to navigate this new world that her father had shielded her from in his own unique way.

This is, in part, a culinary novel, with readers getting immersed recipes throughout. This adds to its flavour (pardon the pun). It also significantly influences how Mimmi eventually reacts to the revelation of the murderer's identity.

The Cinnamon Lady is much more than a book about a crime. It intricately traces Mimmi's profound transformation, which she articulates clearly, as she learns of—and then accepts—the secrets of her father's life.

It is also a journey of reconciliation with her mother, after circumstances had driven them apart. How Mimmi navigates and confronts this new reality, particularly in the aftermath of such a poignant and challenging experience, is the book's core.

White As Far As The Eye Can See

In White As Far As The Eye Can See by Mohamed Abdelrazek (2024), we are taken to a village filled with relationships, secrets, and mysteries.

'White as Far as the Eye Can See' by Mohamed Abdelrazek (Dar El-Ain, 2024)

The novel begins with the death of a young girl, Yasmin, whose family do not know if it was suicide or murder. As they seek the answer, we come to understand the nature of their lives and the stories and secrets they carry.

While the focus is on the crime, which revolves around Yasmin's body, the author manages to introduce us to the characters and their personalities, which allows it to go from a crime story to a psychological and social narrative.

Here, the reader comprehends the dimensions, motivations, and stories of each character of various ages and social positions, including Grandma Halima, who, upon hearing the news, strives to maintain her control.

Recent crime novels have caught the eye for their high standards, mastery of language, and skilled depiction of settings, societies, and eras.

No news of suicide spreads, and no investigation into the cause of death is conducted. However, amidst the shock, things do not unfold according to her wishes.

The author uses an omniscient narrator to introduce family members, their relationships, histories, conflicts, and crises. Between their simple village lives and their aspirations for city life, their dreams are torn apart and lost.

The father, Mas'ad, does all he can to give his family a life away from poverty. His wife, Hala, works in a cotton factory, but she returns to the village in despair.

Alongside them, we encounter other social classes: from the forensic doctor responsible for determining the cause of death, to the police officer investigating the case to the common folk who follow and share the details in bewilderment and defeat.

Longa

In Longa by Mariam Abdel-Aziz (2024), a different world of crime is explored, starting with the disappearance of a resident from a downtown building and the discovery of his body days later by his neighbours, revealing a murder.

'Longa' by Mariam Abdel-Aziz (Al-Kotob Khan, 2024)

We then learn about the victim—a musician—and begin to identify potential suspects, yet from the very first lines, it does more than tell the story of the killer and the crime.

We enter the musician's world in downtown Cairo, getting to know about his life, his problems, and his special relationship with his work. In each paragraph, the author richly depicts the lives of its diverse characters. Music appears at multiple levels, reflected in the structure of the book.

As explained in the novel's introduction, Longa is an "Arab musical form characterised by sudden transitions and speed in performance, consisting of four sections, each section called 'khana' (section) with a repeated part called 'tasleem' (refrain)".

The author employs this structure in her novel, dividing it into four khana sections, through which we learn about the building, its residents, and their relationship with the victim.

There is another death in the book, which seems natural. It is that of a young neighbour called Khalid, nicknamed The Chill. It appears the author intended to create intersections between these two deaths.

Tawfik finds solace only in his oud, pouring out his sighs and sorrows. He is surprised to find that the young man shares a common burden with him, even if he does not fully realise what it is.

The book follows police investigations to a surprise ending, but it is between the world of the murdered musician, the chill young man, and the residents of the building from various social strata, that the novel unfolds.

font change

Related Articles